Best American Restaurants in Fire Island

37 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Butera's Restaurant of Sayville restaurant

1. Butera's Restaurant of Sayville

4.6

Exceptional(1434)

Price: Moderate

• American • Sayville

Booked 21 times today

Butera's Restaurant of Sayville, nestled in the charming town of Sayville, offers a delightful twist on American cuisine with its Italian-inspired menu, ensuring an unforgettable dining experience. Diners rave about the "great service, great food, great atmosphere," with a standout mention for the "family-style chicken parm" that has become a local favorite. The restaurant's ability to "make you feel welcomed" is matched by its "amazing food," ensuring that every visit is memorable. Whether you're sharing a meal with family or enjoying a cozy dinner for two, Butera's consistently delivers "delicious food and attentive staff," making it a must-visit for American cuisine lovers.

A photo of The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails restaurant

2. The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails

4.5

Awesome(252)

Price: Moderate

• American • Sayville

Booked 32 times today

Full service restaurant experience with lively bar. Accomodating for any occasion. Private party room available.

3. Karvers Grille

4.7

Exceptional(1798)

Price: Moderate

• American • Patchogue

Booked 22 times today

Karvers Grille in Patchogue, Holbrook, is a shining example of top-tier Gastro Pub cuisine, celebrated for its dedication to quality and authenticity. This beloved local haunt prides itself on using the freshest ingredients sourced from nearby farms, ensuring each dish bursts with flavor. Patrons rave about the generous portions, with one diner noting that "the food was fresh and tasted great!" The warm, welcoming atmosphere is complemented by friendly staff, making every visit a delightful experience. With consistently "great food and service," Karvers Grille remains a favorite neighborhood gem, enticing both regulars and newcomers to savor its culinary offerings.

A photo of Oakdale Brew House restaurant

4. Oakdale Brew House

4.6

Exceptional(44)

Price: Expensive

• American • Oakdale

Booked 14 times today

Coming Soon!

A photo of Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille restaurant

5. Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille

4.5

Awesome(526)

Price: Moderate

• American • Islip

Booked 42 times today

Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille in East Islip, NY, is a seafood lover's paradise, renowned for its "Best Lobster Rolls on Long Island." This restaurant truly stands out with its commitment to quality, offering dishes that are not only delicious but authentically rich in flavor. Diners rave about the lobster bisque, noting it is "rich and creamy with plenty of lobster pieces." The seafood paella is another highlight, impressing guests with its abundance of lobster, shrimp, calamari, and more. With a warm, inviting atmosphere and attentive service, Jackson Hall is a must-visit for anyone seeking an exceptional seafood experience.

6. View

4.4

Awesome(1913)

Price: Expensive

• American • Oakdale

Booked 10 times today

View in Oakdale is a quintessential American dining experience, offering an exquisite blend of land and sea specialties that delight every palate. With its stunning waterfront location, diners are treated to not only "really good food" but also "one of the best" views on the south shore. The menu impresses with authentic American flavors, featuring dishes like "amazing" tuna poke tacos and perfectly cooked branzino. Reviewers consistently praise the "excellent service" and "delicious" offerings, making it a top choice for both locals and visitors. Whether you're enjoying a meal indoors or taking advantage of the outdoor seating, View promises a memorable dining experience.

A photo of The Oar Steak and Seafood Grill restaurant

7. The Oar Steak and Seafood Grill

4.6

Exceptional(812)

Price: Moderate

• American • Patchogue

Booked 9 times today

The Oar Steak and Seafood Grill is a true gem for lovers of authentic American cuisine, nestled right on the docks of the picturesque Patchogue River. Diners rave about the "delicious food, great cocktails, and amazing ambiance," making it a favorite for many. The restaurant’s menu boasts mouthwatering American classics like the sizzling 36 oz prime porterhouse, and fresh seafood options such as Bluepoint oysters, which are all delivered daily. The charming nautical décor, alongside the stunning waterfront views, creates a dining experience that's "perfect for a first date or even an anniversary dinner." Experience American dining at its finest!

8. The State Room

4.7

Exceptional(90)

Price: Expensive

• American • Patchogue

Booked 6 times today

The State Room in Patchogue offers an exceptional Contemporary American dining experience that stands out for its quality and authenticity. This intimate cocktail lounge crafts a menu inspired by seasonality and responsibly sourced ingredients, ensuring that each dish is fresh and flavorful. Diners rave about the “outstanding flavors and interesting combinations” that make every bite electrifying. The State Room’s cocktails are described as “innovative and lovingly crafted by mixologists,” complementing the exquisite cuisine perfectly. With a speakeasy vibe and warm, attentive service, The State Room is a “hidden gem” that promises an unforgettable dining experience, making it a must-visit for food enthusiasts.

A photo of Ruta Oaxaca - Patchogue restaurant

9. Ruta Oaxaca - Patchogue

4.7

Exceptional(358)

Price: Moderate

• American • Patchogue

Booked 9 times today

Ruta Oaxaca - Patchogue offers a delightful journey into the heart of Contemporary Mexican cuisine, where authenticity and quality take center stage. This vibrant spot is known for its exceptional service and an atmosphere that's both lively and inviting. Diners rave about the "amazing and delish" food, with standout dishes like the Pechuga & Mole Verde praised as "outstanding." The restaurant's dedication to honoring Oaxacan culinary traditions shines through in its exquisite moles, which are more than just sauces—they're the soul of the meal. A visit to Ruta Oaxaca promises an unforgettable dining experience, making it a must-visit for Mexican food enthusiasts.

10. WhiskeyNeat

4.6

Exceptional(53)

Price: Moderate

• American • Patchogue

Booked 7 times today

We’re a food-focused restaurant drawing inspiration from across the culinary landscape—from fine dining and steakhouses, to food trucks, and even grandma’s kitchen—to deliver an innovative menu in a fun and relaxed environment. And we have some whiskey too...

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

M
Marie
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
It was a great experience. It was our second time there we came to celebrate my husband‘s 43rd birthday, and the service was outstanding as well as the food.
More info
Jackson Hall American Bar & GrillePrice: Moderate• American• Islip
•
4.5
B
BlancaVIP
New York City •34 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
We truly enjoyed our sandwiches. Brandon, the bartender was our server because we sat at the booths in that area. He was very attentive.
More info
Karvers GrillePrice: Moderate• American• Patchogue
•
4.7
G
George
New York City •4 reviews
5.0
Dined on 28 Dec 2024
Food was great and service was excellent! Can't wait to go back.
More info
The Wayward Kitchen & CocktailsPrice: Moderate• American• Sayville
•
4.5
J
Jackie
Philadelphia County •1 review
5.0
Dined on 24 Dec 2024
All the food was delicious. Was decorated beautifully and although it was crowded we didn’t feel like we were crammed in. Overall it was a wonderful experience.
More info
Butera's Restaurant of SayvillePrice: Moderate• Italian• Sayville
•
4.6
N
Nick
New York City •10 reviews
5.0
Dined on 21 Dec 2024
Always good food and service at any of the LFRG restaurants. We chose Oakdale Brewhaus because it’s closest to our home. Had a burger, watched a little football, nice waitress. What more could you ask for. The only issue is that parking lot when that playhouse has an event. We had to park behind the post office by a loading dock but all good and worth it.
More info
Oakdale Brew HousePrice: Expensive• American• Oakdale
•
4.6

Explore OpenTable

Fire Island

American

Best American Restaurants in Fire Island

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating options

Accessibility

37 restaurants available nearby

1. Butera's Restaurant of Sayville

2. The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails

3. Karvers Grille

4. Oakdale Brew House

5. Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille

6. View

7. The Oar Steak and Seafood Grill

8. The State Room

9. Ruta Oaxaca - Patchogue

10. WhiskeyNeat

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable