Best American Restaurants in Newcastle

We showed up 45 minutes early by accident for a party of 4 dinner on Valentine's evening, and they were able to seat us right away anyway, which was amazing! We loved our waitress Coka, who was wonderful and very attentive! The restaurant was beautiful with pink napkins and white tablecloths and a lovely fireplace. The place was full of laughter and love. The food was beautifully presented and yummy. Cocktails, too! The service staff was exceptional and went above and beyond to make sure everyone had plates cleared in time between courses. There was no rush for us to eat and leave. We'll be back and can't wait to enjoy it in the summer as well!

Would absolutely recommend this location to anyone looking to have a nice sit down dinner. While the tables are fairly tightly packed so you do feel pretty close to other diners, the food and service well made up for it. We had the calamari as well as the rosemary potato bread for starters, which both came out very quickly and were absolutely delicious. The steaks we had for entrees were perfectly cooked, tender and well seasoned. Our server Shauna was phenomenal the entire time we were there, attentive but not overbearing in any way, did not feel like she was rushing us even though it was a busy night, and had great service generally

The Crawlspace Gastropub is an absolute gem! The food is nothing short of delicious—every dish is thoughtfully prepared and bursting with flavor. The service is impeccable; the staff is attentive, friendly, and makes you feel right at home. We couldn’t be happier to have this amazing spot on the island. If you’re looking for great food, excellent service, and a welcoming atmosphere, Crawlspace Gastro Pub is the place to be! Highly recommend! Let me know if you’d like any tweaks!

Flatbread was Delish! Great Wine recommendation.

Great good and servixe. The weitress was delightful. I will be back for sure.