Best American Restaurants in Pickerington

Great place to get together with friends! Celebrated a birthday here and the happy hour deals are awesome! Highly recommend the half priced pizzas! The chicken Alfredo pizza was awesome and the birthday girl got a free dessert! Highly recommend!

Seated on time. Calm interior, quiet conversation. No background music to be shouted over, which is a big plus, especially if you have hearing aids! Service was attentive. Espressos were admittedly forgotten by the wait staff, which was otherwise excellent. Once she was reminded, it appeared quickly. Onion soup was hot, cheesy and delicious. Risotto notable for superb combination of flavors. The half portion was generously sized. Cheeseburger was actually cooked medium rare, as ordered. Nice to have selection of several sides not just French fries. The sesame bun was toasted perfectly. Traditional condiments required special request as no ketchup or mustard was offered or presented. Main dish was served as we were still eating our soup. They had great Cole slaw! Beverages of the alcoholic type were diverse and apparently satisfying. The dessert menu looked marvelous, but we did not partake of its offerings, choosing espresso instead. One of my criteria for a good restaurant, having a functional pepper mill on the table (and salt), which was on the table when we were seated. Check! The bread items were freshly made and artisanal. The basket arrived automatically and was not added to the tab. Lighting was subdued. Atmosphere was warm, cozy and relaxing. The menu was creative but not off-putting as there were items familiar to most diners, as well. It is nice to be able to select the size of ones entrée, obviating the need for leftovers unless one is a fan of leftovers. Thoroughly delightful experience! This is one of my favorite restaurants in Columbus! I will return again soon!

Overall good, not great, experience for a birthday meal but a few things were off. Dinner rolls a bit on the dry side. Carrot cake ordered by my friend had no nuts. And service seemed a bit slower than past visits.

We love Cooper’s Hawk and have dinner here a couple of times a month. The food was excellent as always, however our server was exceptional tonight! She provided great service and was very personable! Her attention to detail and service were the best we have experienced at any restaurant in a long time!

We had a wonderful experience here this evening! Our waiter, Giovanni, was absolutely incredible. He was attentive, friendly and it was my birthday and he made me feel so special! The food was fantastic and the drinks were delicious. The most amazing thing about this place is the ambiance! The chandeliers, the dim lighting, the waterfall. Being a previous Los Angeles resident, it reminded me of something I would find there. Classy and beautiful! Highly recommend!