Best American Restaurants in West Islip

We returned to the Argyle Grill for dinner, now under new ownership. The interior appears much the same, though it had obviously had a deep cleaning with some lighting and decor changes. Our server Tom was was very nice and was also excited to share his knowledge about the new, upgraded menu. There were plenty of staff assisting in the dining room who were efficient and unobtrusive. The entire meal was creative and delicious. The menu is now mostly a la carte, so the total cost was higher than before, but the quality of the food matched the cost. Best filet mignon I’ve had in recent memory, and the side of roasted cauliflower was plentiful and superb! If it’s in your budget, I recommend you give it a try.

The James has definitely become one of my favorite restaurants! Every staff member is so incredibly nice and helpful! I have difficult food restrictions, and the chef couldn’t be more accommodating. Matt, the Manager is so friendly, and kind, as was Carlos, our server! Perfect way to celebrate my birthday!

Besito is always an exceptional dining experience with its consistently delicious food, warm ambiance, and attentive service. The menu offers dishes prepared with fresh ingredients and bold flavors. The service is exceptional too!

Great value! And amazing quality seafood and taste . Would go again.

I had a reservation for a standard table and they automatically put us at a high top.I told them I did not request a high top amd showed them my emailed reservation, so they had to move us. Although the server was very friendly she was quite slow and not as attentive as she should have been after I told her we needed to be at the theatre and only had a certain amount of time. The menu was a little bit misleading with regards to the prefix. The food was very good.