Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York City

Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Theater District

Price
Regions
Areas
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating options
Award-winning
Accessibility

67 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Max Brenner - Union Square restaurant
1. Max Brenner - Union Square
4.3
Awesome(8071)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Union Square
Booked 115 times today
At the heart of Union Square, New York, Max Brenner - Union Square has been a beacon of comfort food cuisine for over two decades, delighting diners with its rich and indulgent offerings. Known for its enchanting chocolate creations, Max Brenner is more than just desserts; it's a haven for comfort food lovers. From the "best Spicy Rigatoni Vodka" to "delicious Mac and cheese rich and so cheezy," it consistently impresses with both savory and sweet dishes. Guests rave about the "amazing" atmosphere and "very attentive" service, making it a must-visit for those seeking a memorable dining experience. As one reviewer exclaims, "the food here never disappoint," showcasing why Max Brenner remains a beloved spot for comfort food enthusiasts.
A photo of Dolly Varden restaurant
2. Dolly Varden
4.4
Awesome(1013)
Price: Expensive
• Comfort food • Hell's Kitchen
Booked 39 times today
At Dolly Varden in Hell's Kitchen, New York, diners are treated to an authentic American culinary experience that's as memorable as it is delicious. Known for putting playful twists on American classics, this vibrant two-story venue shines with its innovative dishes like the Rail Car burger and truffle mac and cheese. Patrons rave about the quality and creativity of the menu, with glowing reviews highlighting the "incredible" Chicken and Waffles and the "perfectly seasoned" steak and eggs. The ambiance, paired with experiential cocktails like the 5 mimosa flower tower, makes Dolly Varden a must-visit for anyone seeking a standout American dining experience in the heart of Manhattan.
A photo of Carla restaurant
3. Carla
4.7
Exceptional(125)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Hell's Kitchen
Booked 6 times today
Carla in Hell's Kitchen, New York, offers a mesmerizing escape into a world where Fusion / Eclectic cuisine is redefined with soulful food and high-concept cocktails. Nestled in a tropical oasis, Carla's stylish two-story setting provides not just a meal, but an evocative journey blending global influences with unmatched craftsmanship. Patrons rave about the seamless fusion of diverse culinary traditions, with one delighted visitor noting, "Carla’s did it beautifully. Our dishes were magnificent, the service was excellent, and portions were generous." This eclectic dining experience is further enhanced by the warm, familial hospitality and a vibrant atmosphere that makes every visit memorable. Carla truly stands out as a gem in New York's dining scene, delivering an escapist experience that leaves guests planning their next visit.
A photo of Bacall's restaurant
4. Bacall's
4.3
Awesome(1398)
Price: Expensive
• Comfort food • Theater District
Booked 58 times today
Bacall's in New York's vibrant Theater District masterfully captures the essence of Contemporary American cuisine with its dynamic and evolving menu. Diners rave about the "delicious" food, from the perfectly cooked Bronzino to the "top 3 steaks" and succulent brick chicken. The restaurant's flair for the dramatic in both ambiance and plating makes each meal an "experience." With its strategic location and "excellent service," Bacall's is hailed as a perfect pre-theatre dining spot. Patrons consistently praise the diverse menu and the craft cocktails, affirming that Bacall's is a must-visit for anyone seeking authentic and high-quality Contemporary American dining in a beautifully themed setting.
A photo of Bubba Gump - New York restaurant
5. Bubba Gump - New York
4.4
Awesome(462)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Theater District
Booked 64 times today
Bubba Gump Shrimp Co. in New York's Theater District is a haven for Comfort Food lovers, offering a delightful array of southern-style dishes that will transport your taste buds straight to the heart of American cuisine. Known for its vibrant and fun atmosphere, the restaurant serves up a spectacular variety of shrimp dishes, from sautéed to fried, and even shrimp scampi, earning rave reviews like "the shrimp bucket was delicious 😋" and "Always fun to visit Bubba and Gump. The shrimps are so good." Alongside seafood, their award-winning baby back ribs and burgers are a hit amongst diners, perfectly capturing the essence of authentic Comfort Food. Whether it's the friendly staff or the movie-themed ambiance that draws you in, Bubba Gump is a must-visit for a memorable dining experience right in the heart of Times Square.
A photo of Lillie's Union Square restaurant
6. Lillie's Union Square
4.3
Awesome(618)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Chelsea
Booked 3 times today
Lillie's Union Square, nestled in the vibrant neighborhood of Chelsea, New York, serves up an exceptional array of Comfort Food that transports diners back to a cozy, Victorian-era ambiance. With its authentic décor sourced from Belfast, Ireland, Lillie’s offers a uniquely immersive dining experience. Patrons rave about the "mouthwatering burger with seasoned fries" and the "succulent fried shrimp," highlighting the quality and heartiness of the meals. One visitor exclaimed, "The food was to die for!" making it clear that Lillie's commitment to satisfying comfort dishes stands out. Perfect for a weekend brunch or a festive evening, Lillie’s traditional pub fare, coupled with its enchanting atmosphere, ensures a delightful dining experience that resonates with authenticity and charm.
A photo of Somewhere Nowhere NYC restaurant
7. Somewhere Nowhere NYC
4.4
Awesome(194)
Price: Very Expensive
• Comfort food • Chelsea
Booked 30 times today
Somewhere Nowhere NYC, nestled atop the Renaissance New York Chelsea Hotel, has quickly become a Chelsea favorite for its exceptional Comfort Food offerings. Guests rave about the "amazing ambiance" and the "delicious" food that accompanies stunning views of Manhattan. The menu highlights include spicy tacos, grilled cheese with tomato soup, and the much-praised cheese and fruit platter. One patron noted, "The food we had was very good," emphasizing items like tortellini and mushrooms crostini. With its cozy yet chic atmosphere, Somewhere Nowhere NYC delivers an unparalleled dining experience where the quality and authenticity of Comfort Food truly shine.
A photo of Carnegie Diner & Cafe restaurant
8. Carnegie Diner & Cafe
4.5
Awesome(1783)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Midtown West
Booked 115 times today
Carnegie Diner & Cafe in Midtown West, New York, is a treasure trove of Comfort Food that delights every palate. Patrons rave about their experiences, emphasizing both the quality and authenticity of the cuisine. One glowing review exclaims, "BEST pastrami we’ve ever had! Delicious," highlighting the diner's commitment to satisfying hearty appetites with well-loved classics. Another diner recommends, "Highly recommend the spanokopita and half baked chicken," pointing to the versatile and scrumptious menu options available. The bustling, vibrant atmosphere coupled with "superb" service makes it a must-visit spot. It’s no wonder that visitors consistently praise Carnegie Diner & Cafe as their go-to for delectable Comfort Food in NYC.
A photo of Bill's Bar and Burger restaurant
9. Bill's Bar and Burger
4.4
Awesome(2338)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Rockefeller Center
Booked 238 times today
Bill's Bar and Burger in Rockefeller Center, New York City, is a haven for Comfort Food enthusiasts. Praised for its craft burgers, this restaurant offers a standout dining experience that keeps guests coming back for more. Known for the iconic Bill’s ‘Fat Cat’ Burger, ranked among CNN’s “Top 10 Burgers in America,” it’s clear why patrons rave about their meals. A reviewer exclaimed, "The burgers are the showstopper...definitely coming back." The restaurant's vibrant atmosphere, combined with a robust list of local and craft beers, ensures a cheerful and heartwarming experience. From their delicious burgers to the mega peanut butter shake, Bill’s Bar and Burger consistently delivers top-quality comfort food in a welcoming setting.
A photo of Sugar Bar restaurant
10. Sugar Bar
4.5
Awesome(604)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Upper West Side
Booked 8 times today
Sugar Bar on the Upper West Side is a vibrant celebration of Latin and Spanish flavors, where each dish bursts with authenticity and culinary craftsmanship. Diners rave about the "perfectly prepared and seasoned shrimp appetizer" and the "pan-seared Chilean sea bass that's sooo good." The restaurant's Latin influence shines through in its exceptional use of fresh ingredients, creating a homemade feel that guests love. With its lively atmosphere enhanced by live entertainment and the historic charm of Ashford & Simpson's legacy, Sugar Bar isn't just a meal; it's an experience. As one guest puts it, "Everything tasted sooo fresh! 100% my new favorite place!" This establishment is a must-visit for anyone seeking genuine Latin and Spanish cuisine in New York City.

How is content generated

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
  • Phil
    New York City •1 review
    5.0
    Dined 2 days ago
    Great food in a great location. Thanks to Braxton for his amazing service. Food was served piping hot and super tasty. We will visit again.
    More info
    Bubba Gump - New YorkPrice: Moderate• Seafood• Theater District
    •
    4.4
  • Jessica
    Orange County •1 review
    4.0
    Dined 3 days ago
    Absolutely amazing and unique experience!! The terror igloos are absolutely worth it for the overall value of the experience. Food and drinks were delicious, although service was very slow, and our waiter hardly checked on us at all. Would definitely return!!
    More info
    Somewhere Nowhere NYCPrice: Very Expensive• Lounge• Chelsea
    •
    4.4
  • OpenTable Dinervip
    New York City •9 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 4 days ago
    The staff was very attentive & the food tasted very fresh. We had guacamole & chips, shrimp tacos & quesadillas but did not try any of their signature cocktails, though they looked very appealing. The location was very convenient to multiple Broadway theaters which we took advantage of to have pre-matinee lunch. They also have a cute cat robot that they use to deliver drinks, etc., quite a novelty for entertainment.
    More info
    CarlaPrice: Moderate• Comfort Food• Hell's Kitchen
    •
    4.7
  • Kassandravip
    San Francisco Bay Area •4 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 4 days ago
    Dolly Varden was the PERFECT cocktail spot for a birthday get-together I had before a show:) The staff was so nice and attentive to my larger party of 14, and the vibe of the place and decor made it feel like a Christmas cabin getaway. Every drink we had was amazing and the food was wonderful as well! Will surely be back!
    More info
    Dolly VardenPrice: Expensive• Comfort Food• Hell's Kitchen
    •
    4.4
  • Ciara
    Los Angeles •1 review
    5.0
    Dined 5 days ago
    Fabulous!! Nothing bad about this experience! The food was phenomenal and the vibe of the restaurant was so perfect for this time of year! Made a reservation walked in and was seated immediately! Definitely will be visiting again! Highly recommend the steak frites, the pollo Montallo and the creamed spinach! What a great night!
    More info
    Bacall'sPrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Theater District
    •
    4.3

Discover best Comfort Food restaurants in Theater District

Discover the ultimate comfort food destinations in Manhattan's bustling Theater District. Known for its vibrant cultural scene and proximity to Broadway, this area offers a diverse array of eateries specializing in comforting, hearty meals that cater to every palate. From Southern-style dishes and classic American fare to traditional Irish meals and innovative contemporary American cuisine, each restaurant provides a unique take on comfort food, ensuring there's something to satisfy all cravings. Patrons can expect generous portions, a welcoming atmosphere, and service that makes you feel right at home. Reviewers consistently praise the delicious food and outstanding service, highlighting the overall excellent dining experience. Whether you're looking for a cozy spot to unwind after a show or a lively venue to enjoy a meal with friends, the Theater District in New York City is a prime destination for comfort food lovers. Each restaurant's commitment to culinary excellence and a friendly, inviting environment makes it a must-visit for both locals and tourists alike.

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
More
Our sites
Businesses
  • Delight more diners
  • Restaurant Blog
Join us on
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Impressum
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable International Ltd. Alphabeta Building, 14-18 Finsbury Square, London EC2A 1AH - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo