Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Middletown

We were early and the hostess Jane could not have been nicer or more accommodating. Our server Theresa was outstanding, pleasant, knowledgeable and professional. We had three courses all spaced so you could enjoy each course. The food was delicious and a nicer time Then Angelica’s that gets great reviews. I would highly recommend Scratch, much better.

We enjoyed a lovely lunch in the beautiful Pearl restaurant at the Oyster Point Hotel. The view overlooking the river added to the charm of the setting. I had the lamb roll which basically was a French dip with lamb rather than beef. Without a doubt it was one of the most delicious lunches I’ve ever had. Fish and chips were also ordered at our table and it too was delicious. Our server was excellent. She recommended the lamb for which I was very grateful, checked back on us during the meal without being a nuisance. She was friendly without trying to become our new best friend as so many American waiters and waitresses do. We were able to stay as long as wanted without the staff trying to turn over the table for other guests. Her dessert recommendations were again delicious. This is definitely a restaurant I will return to.

Always a positive and delicious experience at Barrel and Roost. Lovely waitstaff and good food in an excellent atmosphere. Get there for the Christmas decor. It is beautiful and fun!

We frequent the Atlantic House, food is always great, the service is best in class and the atmosphere is always lively. The blue cheese chips are a great starter as are the Pot of Clams.

We went for Thanksgiving dinner. Disappointed that it was 'deli' turkey, and not carved off the bird. Also disappointed with the little dollop of whipped cream on the pumpkin pie. The sides were delicious, especially the mashed potatoes. I also enjoyed the seasonal drink - Midnight Harvest. Our server Matt was the best.