Best Comfort Food Restaurants in New Milford

10 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Maggiano's - Hackensack restaurant

1. Maggiano's - Hackensack

4.6

Exceptional(2784)

Price: Moderate

• Comfort food • Hackensack

Booked 12 times today

At Maggiano's in Hackensack, nestled in the upscale Shops at Riverside Mall, authentic Italian-American cuisine comes to life with dishes that echo the warmth of Nonna's kitchen. Patrons rave about the "absolutely the best Italian food" they've had in years, where classics like the chicken franchese are dubbed "the best!!" The inviting ambiance, complemented by exceptional service, sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. Customers frequently highlight the generous portions and reasonable prices, making every meal a celebration. Indulge in favorites like the mushroom ravioli or the stuffed mushrooms, and let Maggiano's transport you to the heart of Italy with every bite.

A photo of Houlihan's - Paramus restaurant

2. Houlihan's - Paramus

3.9

Excellent(187)

Price: Moderate

• Comfort food • Paramus

Booked 9 times today

Since 1972, we've believed in quality ingredients, cooking from scratch and having fun. From our famous 'Shrooms and Stuffed Chicken Breast to our unique burger blend and ahi tuna, we believe in celebrating the small things and that every moment deserves a toast in its honor. So grab a drink (perhaps our signature Long Island Iced Tea), enjoy some great conversation and let us serve you an excellent meal.

A photo of Ho-Ho-Kus Inn & Tavern restaurant

3. Ho-Ho-Kus Inn & Tavern

4.5

Awesome(1493)

Price: Moderate

• Comfort food • Ho-Ho-Kus

Booked 15 times today

Experience the quintessence of Contemporary American cuisine at the Ho-Ho-Kus Inn & Tavern, nestled in Ho-Ho-Kus, New Jersey. This historic inn, revitalized with a $1.5 million renovation, offers a unique blend of American classics within a cozy, inviting atmosphere highlighted by its original fireplaces and charming dining spaces. Awarded the Wine Spectator Award of Excellence eight times, the Inn provides a culinary adventure with its seasonal menus that captivate both locals and visitors alike. Guests rave about the "delicious and abundant food" and "top-shelf service," making every dining experience memorable. Whether it's enjoying crafted cocktails by the bluestone patio's fireplace or savoring the special Red Snapper and Zucchini Flowers, Ho-Ho-Kus Inn & Tavern stands out as a pinnacle of superb dining and exemplary service in Bergen County.

4. Hudson Social - Dobbs Ferry

4.3

Awesome(414)

Price: Moderate

• Comfort food • Dobbs Ferry

Nestled in the historic Dobbs Ferry train station house, Hudson Social offers a culinary retreat with its standout Burgers cuisine that promises to delight every palate. Patrons rave about the "hot delicious" burgers, emphasizing not only their taste but also the picturesque views of the Hudson River that complement the dining experience. Known for using all-natural and local ingredients, Hudson Social ensures every burger is crafted to perfection, making it a must-visit for burger enthusiasts. Reviews consistently highlight the exceptional service and ambient setting, making it a top recommendation for anyone seeking a memorable burger experience in Dobbs Ferry.

A photo of Marcus Live Bar & Grille restaurant

5. Marcus Live Bar & Grille

3.8

Excellent(60)

Price: Moderate

• Comfort food • East Rutherford

Located within the retail and entertainment complex American Dream and adjacent to Meadowlands Sports Complex, Marcus Live Bar & Grille serves as a culinary centerpiece for visitors and an escape from city life. Led by Chef Marcus Samuelsson and with a menu emblematic of his personal cooking style, Marcus Live features everything from oysters on the half shell and tavern-style pizza to an assortment of steaks and barbecue to a selection of his signature items like Brown Sugar Wings and Old Bay Crab Cakes. There are also large format, shareable options, such as the "Garden State Jubilee" with rice and peas, grilled shrimp, fried chicken, sliced ribeye, vegetable couscous, and charred broccolini with optional surf and turf upgrades. In addition to the dining options, the lively bar will feature an impressive wine list, craft beers, and creative cocktails.

A photo of House of Que - American Dream Mall restaurant

6. House of Que - American Dream Mall

4.7

Exceptional(24)

Price: Moderate

• Comfort food • East Rutherford

House of Que at American Dream Mall in East Rutherford, New Jersey, is the epitome of authentic American cuisine, particularly celebrated for its Austin-style BBQ. The expertise of Pit Master/Chef Michael Rodriguez, who brings over 20 years of BBQ mastery, is evident in every bite of their slow-smoked meats. Patrons rave about the "best ribs I've ever had" and the brisket, described as "lean and full of flavor." The restaurant's atmosphere enhances the dining experience with state-of-the-art TVs and live performances, making it not just a meal but an event. As one reviewer encapsulated, "The food was AMAZING!!! My server Angeline was super nice and went out of her way to make sure me and my party were all satisfied. Will definitely come back." House of Que is a must-visit for anyone seeking a genuine taste of American BBQ excellence.

A photo of Giovanni's Bicycle Club restaurant

7. Giovanni's Bicycle Club

4.2

Awesome(205)

Price: Moderate

• Comfort food • Englewood Cliffs

Giovanni's Bicycle Club in Englewood Cliffs is a beacon of American cuisine, delighting diners since 1969 with its authentic and high-quality dishes. Patrons rave about the "exceptional" Margarita pie and the "truly amazing" desert tartufo bomba, highlighting the restaurant's ability to elevate classic American offerings. Reviews consistently praise the "superior service" and the "fabulous" food, underscoring its reputation as a "true neighborhood gem." Whether it's for a casual brunch or a special dinner, Giovanni's Bicycle Club promises an enjoyable atmosphere where every meal is a testament to the best of American culinary traditions. It's no wonder it's a favored destination in Bergen County for both locals and visitors alike.

8. Villa Amalfi

4.5

Awesome(170)

Price: Expensive

• Comfort food • Cliffside Park

Booked 1 time today

Upscale Italian restaurant with classic furnishing, old school white table clothes, and delicious dishes rooted from the Amalfi Coast

9. Casa Mia Yonkers

4.4

Awesome(47)

Price: Moderate

• Comfort food • Yonkers

Casa Mia Yonkers is a beacon of authentic Pizzeria cuisine in Yonkers, consistently praised for its delicious offerings and warm ambiance. With glowing reviews such as "The next pizza anywhere and my wife and I love to eat there," and "Best food and service ever!! Pizza is one of the best I've had," it's clear that Casa Mia stands out for its high-quality, scrumptious pizzas. Reviewers consistently highlight the pizza's exceptional taste and the restaurant's commitment to service, making it a must-visit for anyone seeking a genuine slice of Italy in Yonkers. Whether dining in or ordering out, Casa Mia Yonkers delivers a culinary experience that leaves customers craving for more.

A photo of Houlihan's - Secaucus restaurant

10. Houlihan's - Secaucus

4.3

Awesome(172)

Price: Moderate

• Comfort food • Secaucus

Booked 8 times today

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

M
Mariano
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Our server was amazing and she answered all our questions and concerns
More info
Maggiano's - HackensackPrice: Moderate• Italian• Hackensack
•
4.6
A
Alexia
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Nice bar/restaurant for brunch. We were looking for a quiet place for brunch Christmas week and stumbled upon this establishment. The greeter/waiter, Cameron, was friendly and helpful. The food was delicious and the drinks were great too! Definitely recommend it and will be back soon!
More info
Dolly VardenPrice: Expensive• Comfort Food• Hell's Kitchen
•
4.3
P
Patty
Greater Boston •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
We had breakfast at the Carnegie on Saturday, Dec, 21. NYC was very busy before the holidays and the Carnegie was no exception. That being said the Carnegie exceeded our expectations. Despite the Carnegie being at capacity, the manager handled the wait/customers very well, the server was excellent and the food was amazing and well timed. The noice level is what it is. This is a busy diner, and we thought it had a fun atmosphere. We will definitely return.
More info
Carnegie Diner & Café – 205 W 57th St, New York, NYPrice: Moderate• American• Midtown West
•
4.6
M
Mark
Washington, D.C. Area •1 review
5.0
Dined on 14 Dec 2024
Our waitress was amazing and so nice! Everything we ordered was very good! We would definitely go back again.
More info
CarlaPrice: Moderate• Comfort Food• Hell's Kitchen
•
4.7
E
eric
New York City •2 reviews
4.0
Dined on 13 Dec 2024
Ordered the spinach dip with the cheesy lavosh (always our favorite) Scallops and french dip sandwich. Both were great. We went for the holidays and ordered some of the seasonal drinks which were not as great as the food but overall was a good time!
More info
Houlihan's - ParamusPrice: Moderate• American• Paramus
•
3.9

Explore OpenTable

New Milford

Comfort food

Best Comfort Food Restaurants in New Milford

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating options

Award-winning

Accessibility

10 restaurants available nearby

1. Maggiano's - Hackensack

2. Houlihan's - Paramus

3. Ho-Ho-Kus Inn & Tavern

4. Hudson Social - Dobbs Ferry

5. Marcus Live Bar & Grille

6. House of Que - American Dream Mall

7. Giovanni's Bicycle Club

8. Villa Amalfi

9. Casa Mia Yonkers

10. Houlihan's - Secaucus

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable