Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Oak Bluffs

Fabulous with a Capital “F” WellDone.,., Beautiful Atmosphere.. excellent staff.. quality cuisine

We ordered the special Wygau for two with mash potatoes and brussel sprouts. For $80 I expected more food. I understand the steak is expensive, that wasn't the issue. There was barely any brussel sprouts and not enough mashed potatoes. Our server Stephanie was attentive although it was very busy due to Valentines day. Overall a good experience. Very modern restaurant will come back

I can't say enough about our Valentine's Day experience. Everything was perfect. Absolutely worth even more than what we paid. It's a beautiful view; being right on the beach. We went right during "golden hour" and all the colors were spectacular. See? I haven't even gotten to the food! Our meal started with a lovely complimentary "toast" for Valentine's Day. Then we had warm bread and a butternut lobster bisque to die for. Then my wife enjoyed a lovely cold meal served in this absolutely beautiful bowl/plate that was so beautiful and original. My "Land and Sea" couldn't have been better. The shrimp was nice and poppy, asparagus crisp, and the sauces were excellent. But the steak, whew, the steak was absolutely incredible. I seriously cannot say enough about it. Cooked perfectly, it just melted in my mouth. I swear it was the best steak I've ever had. Lastly our desserts were beautifully presented to us. I had an eggnog creme brulee, with fruits and cornbread atop. Extraordinary. My wife had a chocolate lava cake with blood orange sherbet. They also went a bit further with hers and even wrote Happy Valentine's Day on the plate in chocolate sauce. Chef's kiss. Lastly the service was impeccable. The door was opened for us right away, and from there it only got better. Our waitress, Kristen, was super friendly, had some great suggestions and made sure that our drinks were never even less than 1/4 full. Why are you still reading? Get going! Seriously, this place is a "must go".

Party of three in the perfect igloo for a beautiful sunset. The service was very good. Calamari , chowder, clam fritters, lobster pasta and short rib tacos were all exceptionally delicious! We will return to The Reef.

One of our favorite island restaurants. Always guaranteed to get a great meal. The food always tastes delicious. Perfectly seasoned with great flavors. Never bland. Service always great from the hostess to the servers to the bussers.