Best Italian Restaurants in Old West Austin

First time at Dean’s, celebrating a birthday dinner. The entrance to the restaurant is a little narrow and we were stuck behind another couple waiting for the hostess, over 5 mins which felt slightly awkward. Upon being seated we were greeted promptly with an extensive wine list, (not a big wine enthusiast) however we enjoyed the cocktails. I had a potent yet tasty Oaxacan mezcal old fashioned, she had a spicy cucumber

Sampled several appetizers and shared entrees which was more than enough food. Really great dishes and incredible (hard to find) wines to enhance the experience. Actually less expensive than I was expecting and good value for an exceptional dinner. Wait staff was attentive without being intrusive. Lizagna had a sense of humor too.

First time: Made reservations about two months in advance— the place was packed! Everyone was either celebrating something or spending time with loved ones. A great atmosphere! The food was outstanding, a great selection of wines and liquors at the bar. Service was faster than expected, especially considering how busy the place was. Reasonable prices all-around and excellent experience from the staff and the atmosphere.

If pizza is your thing the margherita pizza with fior di latte mozzarella takes you back to the wonderful pizzas in Northern Italy. The swordfish was outstanding. The service superior. What else could you want.

Really enjoyed all aspects of our evening at Poeta. Antipasti Salad and Roasted Cauliflower were great starters. Seared Bass was fantastic with the tomato pesto...will be thinking of how to recreate that at home. Exceptional value for the service and quality.