Best Italian Restaurants in Coney Island

83 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Gargiulo's Coney Island restaurant

1. Gargiulo's Coney Island

4.8

Exceptional(803)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Coney Island

Booked 11 times today

At Gargiulo's Coney Island, nestled in the vibrant heart of Brooklyn, you'll discover a slice of Italy renowned for its authenticity and rich tradition. Celebrated for its "divine" Italian cuisine, Gargiulo’s serves up traditional Neapolitan dishes crafted from family recipes that have been cherished since 1907. Patrons rave about the "outstanding" Trofie pasta with pesto and the "perfect" lamb chops, highlighting the fresh, high-quality ingredients. The atmosphere is described as an "Italian villa," adding to the authentic experience. As one reviewer put it, the house-made cannoli is "out of this world," making Gargiulo's a must-visit for anyone seeking the true essence of Italian dining in New York City.

A photo of Michael's of Brooklyn restaurant

2. Michael's of Brooklyn

4.9

Exceptional(906)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Midwood

Booked 14 times today

At Michael's of Brooklyn, nestled in the scenic Midwood neighborhood, seafood lovers are treated to an exceptional dining experience that has charmed diners since 1964. This family-owned gem is renowned for its commitment to authentic Italian culinary traditions, with seafood dishes that consistently receive glowing accolades for their freshness and flavor. Patrons rave about the "famous fried lobster" and the freshness of the "oysters on the half shell," highlighting how each dish is "cooked to perfection." The elegant ambiance, complemented by live piano music, enhances the dining experience, making Michael's of Brooklyn a must-visit for anyone seeking the best seafood in the city.

3. Positano

4.8

Exceptional(605)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Bay Ridge

Booked 15 times today

Positano is an Italian restaurant located in a quaint section of Bay Ridge. We offer Italian American cuisine with an emphasis on seafood, dry-aged steaks, homemade fresh pasta dishes and more! Perfect for families, a date, or an event! We are an upbeat locale with both indoor and outdoor dining offered.

A photo of Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Bay Ridge restaurant

4. Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Bay Ridge

4.8

Exceptional(94)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bay Ridge

Booked 14 times today

At Campania Coal Fired Pizza in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, the essence of authentic Italian cuisine is celebrated with every dish served. Renowned for its unique coal-fired pizzas, the restaurant offers a distinct smoky flavor that enhances the crispy crust and fresh toppings, making it a standout in New York City. Patrons rave about the "perfectly crispy crust" and "flavorful sauce" that elevate classics like the Margherita and innovative creations such as the Calabrese. Beyond pizza, the menu features Italian favorites from hearty sandwiches to exquisite pasta dishes, all prepared with the freshest ingredients. The warm, inviting atmosphere and consistently exceptional service make Campania a beloved destination for both locals and visitors, ensuring a delightful dining experience that's both "impeccable" and "family-friendly." As one reviewer puts it, this place is "100/10" for anyone craving top-notch Italian fare in a cozy setting.

5. Cavatappi

4.9

Exceptional(57)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Bensonhurst

Booked 5 times today

Welcome to Cavatappi Italian Restaurant - a family owned & operated establishment - located in the heart of Dyker Heights in Brooklyn. Our modern and cozy atmosphere is the perfect setting for a delicious meal. Our menu features a variety of classic Italian dishes, as well as some unique twists. Be sure to try our signature Kansas City pork chop, pan seared then baked to perfection and served with a side of parsnip apple sauce. Whether you're in the mood for pasta, seafood, or a hearty meat dish, we have something for everyone.We look forward to serving you at Cavatappi Italian Restaurant, where you can enjoy adelicious meal in a warm and inviting atmosphere. Buon apetito!

A photo of Il Colosseo Restaurant And Pizzeria restaurant

6. Il Colosseo Restaurant And Pizzeria

4.8

Exceptional(66)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bensonhurst

Booked 2 times today

Il Colosseo Restaurant and Pizzeria, nestled in the vibrant Bensonhurst neighborhood of Brooklyn, has earned a reputation as a top destination for exquisite Vegan Italian cuisine. Diners consistently rave about the "authentically Italian" flavors and the "truly magnificent" dining experience. From the intimate and cozy atmosphere to the open kitchen where culinary magic unfolds, Il Colosseo offers a delightful vegan menu that stands out for its creativity and adherence to traditional Italian tastes. Patrons highlight dishes like the eggplant Parmesan and linguine with garlic and EVOO, praising them for being "perfectly seasoned" and "bursting with authentic flavors." Whether you're a local or just visiting, Il Colosseo promises a memorable vegan meal that captures the essence of Italian culinary artistry.

A photo of Patrizia's Of Sheepshead Bay restaurant

7. Patrizia's Of Sheepshead Bay

4.2

Awesome(2)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Sheepshead Bay

Booked 2 times today

Patrizia’s has been a family oriented concept for over 25 years. Each Patrizia's location is individually owned and operated to ensure that your dining experience at Patrizia’s is always great. As with Italian tradition, every single customer is treated like family. Each dish is prepared with fresh organic ingredients that uses family recipes dating back over 150 years. Aside from dining in, we also provide pick-up, delivery and catering for all occasions. Superb food, impeccable service, and a unique family atmosphere distinguishes Patrizia’s from any other restaurant and makes it a one of a kind experience. With locations in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, The Bronx, Staten Island, Long Island (Hicksville, Massapequa, Commack & Hauppauge), Sheepshead Bay, Manhattan, Maspeth Queens, Red Bank, New Jersey & our always sunny locations in Fort Lauderdale, Deerfield Beach Florida & Aruba...Amazing family style dining is just around the corner.

8. Ponte Vecchio

4.7

Exceptional(156)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bay Ridge

Booked 10 times today

Ponte Vecchio in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, offers a premier seafood dining experience that continually impresses locals and visitors alike. Known for its exquisite Italian cuisine, the restaurant shines with its seafood offerings. Guests rave about the "best Chilean sea bass" and "fresh & delicious mussels in white wine garlic," highlighting the quality and freshness of their dishes. The "wonderful" soft shell crab and "spectacular" Spaghetti Fruit del Mare also receive high praise, ensuring that each plate is a testament to Ponte Vecchio’s commitment to authentic and delectable seafood. With over 35 years of culinary excellence, Ponte Vecchio remains a beloved destination for those seeking exceptional seafood and a memorable dining ambiance.

9. Greenhouse Cafe

4.5

Awesome(245)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Bay Ridge

Nestled in the heart of Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, Greenhouse Cafe stands out as a beacon of American cuisine. Celebrated for its "delicious and fresh" food and "excellent service," this local gem has been a favorite for nearly two decades. Diners rave about the variety of dishes and "ample portions," with specialties like the "SERF AND TERF" receiving special mention. The ambiance, whether you choose indoors or the beautiful greenhouse room, consistently earns high marks for being family-friendly and the perfect spot for both casual dining and special events. Greenhouse Cafe not only promises but delivers an authentic and memorable American dining experience, making it a must-visit destination in Brooklyn.

10. Don Cheech

4.7

Exceptional(236)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Shore Acres

Booked 8 times today

At Don Cheech in Shore Acres, Staten Island, the essence of classic American cuisine is brilliantly captured with an Italian twist. Executive Chef Massimo Felici's culinary prowess shines through dishes that are both nostalgic and innovative, offering a slice of old-school NYC Little Italy on every plate. Patrons rave about the authenticity and quality, with one noting, "The food was amazing...Always a favorite! So grateful to have Don Cheech in the neighborhood." With its elegant atmosphere and personable service, Don Cheech stands out as a beacon of superb dining. Whether it’s the Stuffed Long Hots, Chicken Parmigiana, or the exquisite Seafood Salad, each dish is a testament to Chef Massimo’s dedication to elevating American classics.

How is content generated

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

S
Scott
New York City •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
I’ve been eating at this restaurant for many many years. I love everything on the menu impeccable service amazing food great restaurant.
More info
Michael's of BrooklynPrice: Expensive• Italian• Midwood
•
4.9
M
Margueritevip
New York City •33 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Such a nice neighborhood gem. the food and service were top-notch. Special shout out to bartender Alessia (sp?) who made excellent drinks & so nice to talk to.
More info
PositanoPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Bay Ridge
•
4.8
J
Joseph
San Antonio •10 reviews
5.0
Dined on 14 Nov 2024
Always a wonderful meal! Wait staff are well trained and attentive!
More info
Gargiulo's Coney IslandPrice: Expensive• Italian• Coney Island
•
4.8
G
Gene
New York City •7 reviews
5.0
Dined on 9 Nov 2024
That was a busiest Saturday night I have ever seen. Barely made reservation for 5 people, but table was ready when we arrived. Service was wonderful and the food excellent ! Red sangria is boosey and tasty . Worth every penny. When we were leaving there was a line to get in on the street.
More info
Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Bay RidgePrice: Expensive• Pizzeria• Bay Ridge
•
4.8
M
Maria
Hawaii •1 review
5.0
Dined on 7 Sept 2024
The food was amazing! The service was great! We would come back and get a different meal. We got the special seafood risotto and the Bronzino in red sauce. They were both delicious!
More info
CavatappiPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Bensonhurst
•
4.9

Discover best Italian restaurants in Coney Island

Discover the charm of Italian cuisine right in the heart of Coney Island, Brooklyn. This vibrant dining scene offers a delightful array of Italian eateries, each serving up authentic dishes that transport diners straight to Italy. From traditional pasta dishes and savory pizzas to sophisticated seafood and meat specialties, the variety is impressive and caters to all tastes. Each restaurant prides itself on using fresh, high-quality ingredients, ensuring that every meal is as flavorful as it is satisfying. Whether you're looking for a cozy spot for a romantic dinner or a lively venue for a family gathering, Coney Island's Italian restaurants provide the perfect setting. Immerse yourself in the rich flavors and warm ambiance that these establishments have to offer, making your dining experience truly memorable. With a focus on culinary excellence and genuine hospitality, Coney Island proves to be a top destination for Italian food lovers.

Explore OpenTable

Coney Island

Italian

Best Italian Restaurants in Coney Island

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating options

Award-winning

Accessibility

83 restaurants available nearby

1. Gargiulo's Coney Island

2. Michael's of Brooklyn

3. Positano

4. Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Bay Ridge

5. Cavatappi

6. Il Colosseo Restaurant And Pizzeria

7. Patrizia's Of Sheepshead Bay

8. Ponte Vecchio

9. Greenhouse Cafe

10. Don Cheech

See what locals rave about

Discover best Italian restaurants in Coney Island

Explore OpenTable