Best Italian Restaurants in Middletown

We had the best time at Osteria. Our waitress was very professional and attentive. The lobster bisque was delicious, and so were the scallops. The tiramisu was the perfect end to the evening. We'll definitely be coming back.

Great food and service but need a quieter area for a large party so that all can hear each other; we were seated next to another large party. Our server was great and kindly turned down the music that was coming through speakers close to our table. That helped!

Great food. It was hot. It was well timed. It was delicious. Short ribs and shrimp with pasta. Great selections. Food and wine. Attentive employees. Sincerely friendly. Is there anything you can do about the acoustics? Very difficult to converse without really yelling. If I owned the facility, I would seek professional help with sound dampening.

Great spot to meet friends for good food and service. Easy to access with parking at the door. Will return often

Arrived 5 minutes before reservation and seated right away. Greeted by our server Ashley who was outstanding. Was offered cocktail and wine list and had drinks within 5 minutes. 1st time for my friend so she was greeted with toast of Chianti and Italian toast. Salad and main course were exceptional. One of my favorite restaurants.