Best Italian Restaurants in Milton

2nd trip there and the food and service was amazing. Had Keith as our waiter and he is the best. Couldn’t ask for a better experience. Definitely will visit again

As first-time diners at Rena’s, we were thrilled with every aspect of our experience. From the moment we walked in, we were warmly greeted and promptly seated (thanks to our reservation). Our server, Brian, was exceptional—friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable. He guided us to some incredible dishes and even let us sample a few wines, which led us to selections we’d never have tried otherwise. The manager, Drew, made us feel especially welcome, checking in several times throughout the evening to ensure everything was perfect. The food was outstanding. The butternut squash soup was the best I’ve ever had—rich, flavorful, and comforting. The stuffed mushroom caps brought back nostalgic memories of my mother’s cooking. For our entrées, the seasonal pork chop with risotto was hearty and perfectly suited for a chilly night, while the shrimp and scallops over pasta were equally fantastic. A special shoutout to the bread service—it’s not to be missed! We were so full that we took half of our meal home, saving room for dessert. The cheesecake was delightful, and the espresso martinis were the perfect finishing touch. From start to finish, the service and food were top-notch. We enjoyed ourselves thoroughly and can’t wait to return often.

We had such a wonderful experience at Colletta tonight. The staff was very friendly and made us feel very welcomed. They went above and beyond to make sure we had a great night. We will be back!

What a wonderful first time experience dining at Vinny’s. Food was delicious, cocktails were on point and service at the bar by Louie (??) was top notch! Will be returning very soon! Cheers!

Our favorite restaurant to go to for special occasions for many years. We were last there on a Saturday night which was an open mike night when diners can help entertain. Randy, their fantastically talented piano player and Casey {the owner} has a beautiful voice and sings, talks to diners and helps celebrate birthdays. It was a fun and entertaining evening. Best time to go is on weekends.