Best Italian Restaurants in Pawling

From the food to the staff everything is perfect. They really try to make your time there the best it can be. Food is delicious and the staff are all great. Challenge you to find another place as good as this.

We love Cafe on the Green for gatherings with friends and families when we're in town (as we moved away from the area.) Owner Tracey Kydes goes out of his way to make everything right. His staff is hard working and friendly. Great food, food coupled with attentive service from the staff. Excellent team work from the front of the house back to the kitchen. Solid value prop and the dining room is spacious enough to enjoy conversation without it getting too loud. We visited on New Years Day 2025...very pleasant experience (as usual!)

Overall a great experience on Christmas Eve. The food was delicious, servers were attentive and the decor for the holidays was lovely. Prices were a little steep for drinks, but I'd definitely go back.

A wonderful experience as always! Pepe and crew of welcoming, and attentive. The menu in diverse and the food is prepared perfectly. The specials are always a treat. Portions generous but not over so. Prices are reasonable.

Overly generous portions, extensive menu and extremely fairly priced. Service is top notch, wait staff is accomodating and patient. Place is immaculate, you can eat off the floors. Food was incredibly tasteful, absolute perfection from top to bottom. Would HIGHLY recommend!!!