Best Southwest American Restaurants in Sanibel

13 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Thistle Lodge Restaurant restaurant

1. Thistle Lodge Restaurant

4.3

Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Sanibel

Booked 2 times today

Grand Views... Rave Reviews. At the Thistle Lodge Beachfront Restaurant, delicious cuisine is served in a historical heirloom setting overlooking the Gulf of Mexico. Swaying palms and gently breaking waves further set the scene for romance.

A photo of Rosalita's Cantina restaurant

2. Rosalita's Cantina

4.5

Awesome(2)

Price: Moderate

• Mexican • Sanibel

Sanibel’s premier option for classic Tex-Mex cuisine, serving classic drinks and eats in a breathtaking atmosphere.Unfortunately, Rosalita's Cantina does not take online reservations or waitlist. However, we proudly take any size walk-in. See you soon!

A photo of JWB Grill Fort Myers Beach restaurant

3. JWB Grill Fort Myers Beach

4.6

Exceptional(425)

Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Fort Myers Beach

Booked 22 times today

JWB Grill is quintessential cool overlooking the Gulf of Mexico. Step into JWB Grill and escape the everyday with spectacular off-the-boat seafood, prime steaks, curated wines, and signature Margaritaville cocktails. The experience is always fresh and cool with our seasonal menu that absolutely delights the senses. Our beachside paradise features live entertainment, bar with a vibe, and welcomes all (resort guests and those visiting just for dinner) with laid-back luxury and a hint of sophistication. Reservations are strongly encouraged. Plan ahead - our entire resort is cash-less.

A photo of Rae's Real Italian restaurant

4. Rae's Real Italian

4.5

Awesome(270)

Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Fort Myers

Booked 7 times today

Rae's Real Italian in Fort Myers Beach offers an authentic American dining experience that captures the essence of gourmet Italian cuisine with a unique American twist. Nestled within the scenic Pink Shell Beach Resort and Marina, Rae's provides a delightful fusion of traditional and contemporary flavors that cater to all ages. Guests rave about the "best meal we had all weekend" and praise the "unique and delicious" Key Lime Cannolis, highlighting the restaurant's commitment to quality and creativity. With its stunning Gulf of Mexico views and exceptional service, Rae's Real Italian is not just a meal; it's a culinary journey that resonates deeply with the American palate, making it a must-visit destination on Fort Myers Beach.

5. The Green Flash

4.7

Exceptional(945)

Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Captiva Island

Booked 15 times today

At The Green Flash on Captiva Island, Florida, the cocktail bar is a highlight, boasting an exceptional selection of drinks that perfectly complement the stunning waterfront views. Patrons rave about the quality and creativity of the cocktails, with one guest exclaiming, "Great food amazing drinks, along with a fun and friendly staff!" The ambiance of the bar, combined with the attentive service, makes for a memorable experience. Whether arriving by boat or car, The Green Flash offers a perfect blend of delectable drinks and scenic beauty, making it a must-visit destination for cocktail enthusiasts seeking both flavor and charm.

A photo of Gather - Cape Coral restaurant

6. Gather - Cape Coral

4.7

Exceptional(121)

Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Cape Coral

Booked 17 times today

Gather - Cape Coral, situated in the picturesque Tarpon Point Marina, is a culinary gem known for its exceptional Fusion / Eclectic cuisine. This waterfront dining spot delights with a symphony of traditional and Mediterranean flavors, ingeniously melded with classic dishes to offer a unique international twist. Patrons rave about the "mouthwatering blackened shrimp with sweet potato gnocchi" and the "fantastic" salmon special, highlighting the restaurant's commitment to creativity and quality. Complemented by an "amazing wine list" and craft cocktails, Gather ensures each visit is a memorable gastronomic journey. As one reviewer put it, Gather is "a little gem on the water," making it a must-visit for an unparalleled dining experience in Cape Coral.

7. Next Door

5.0

Exceptional(149)

Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Cape Coral

Booked 5 times today

Next Door in Cape Coral offers an exceptional dining experience that highlights the best of Contemporary American cuisine with a delightful modern twist. Patrons consistently rave about the unique and delicious flavor combinations, such as the "basil infused pasta" and the "wagyu carpaccio," underscoring the chef's skill in elevating traditional dishes. One reviewer exclaimed, "The chef nailed it with the unexpected & complimentary tasting of the asparagus puree with microgreens," emphasizing the creativity and quality that Next Door brings to every dish. Frequent guests appreciate not only the food but also the atmosphere, describing it as their "favorite date nightspot." With its commitment to freshness, evident in their daily handmade pastas, and a market for those who wish to bring a taste of Next Door home, this restaurant truly stands out in the Cape Coral culinary scene.

8. Old Captiva House

4.9

Exceptional(2078)

Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Captiva Island

Booked 13 times today

Discover the essence of American cuisine at Old Captiva House, nestled in the heart of Captiva Island. This gem is celebrated for its "New Florida" menu that brilliantly showcases the richness of local flavors through an array of dishes meticulously crafted to please every palate. Patrons rave about the "exceptional food" and the "amazing view of the sunset" that accompanies dining experiences here. With accolades like “the BEST Duck L’Orange I have ever had” and “grouper with lobster risotto was amazing,” it's clear Old Captiva House offers a unique blend of traditional American fare with a delightful island twist. The restaurant consistently earns high praise for both its vibrant setting and its culinary excellence, making it a must-visit destination for an authentic and memorable American dining experience.

A photo of Fathoms Restaurant & Bar restaurant

9. Fathoms Restaurant & Bar

4.2

Awesome(87)

Price: Moderate

• Mexican • Cape Coral

Booked 2 times today

Fathoms Restaurant & Bar in Cape Coral is a true gem for anyone craving authentic American cuisine. With its vibrant atmosphere and stunning marina views, it's the perfect spot for both casual diners and food connoisseurs. Patrons rave about their hand-crafted pizzas and "the best burger you’ll ever have," priced at a value that leaves guests eager to return. The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident as reviewers highlight the "exceptional food" and "outstanding service," with one noting, "The food is always consistent and never ceases to amaze!" Whether it's the lively tiki bar or the inviting indoor seating, Fathoms is a must-visit for an unforgettable dining experience where the American fare shines brilliantly.

A photo of Marker 92 Waterfront Bar & Bistro restaurant

10. Marker 92 Waterfront Bar & Bistro

4.6

Exceptional(474)

Price: Moderate

• Mexican • Cape Coral

Booked 5 times today

Nestled within the scenic Westin Cape Coral at Tarpon Point Marina, Marker 92 Waterfront Bar & Bistro offers an exceptional seafood dining experience that is as delightful as its surroundings. Patrons rave about the "top-notch" food, highlighting the "delicious" blackened grouper sandwich and the "fabulous" salmon, which are just a glimpse of their diverse seafood offerings. This gem provides a perfect blend of ambience and culinary excellence, with views over the harbor enhancing the dining experience. Guests consistently praise the restaurant’s ability to deliver "fabulous food" and "superb service," making it an unbeatable choice for seafood lovers visiting or residing in Cape Coral. Whether you arrive by boat or by land, the welcoming atmosphere and expertly prepared dishes ensure a memorable meal.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Sanibel

Mexican

Best Southwest American Restaurants in Sanibel

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating options

Accessibility

13 restaurants available nearby

1. Thistle Lodge Restaurant

2. Rosalita's Cantina

3. JWB Grill Fort Myers Beach

4. Rae's Real Italian

5. The Green Flash

6. Gather - Cape Coral

7. Next Door

8. Old Captiva House

9. Fathoms Restaurant & Bar

10. Marker 92 Waterfront Bar & Bistro

Explore OpenTable