5 Best Pizzerias In West Caldwell

5 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Panevino Ristorante restaurant

1. Panevino Ristorante

4.7

Exceptional(959)

Price: Moderate

• Pizzeria • Livingston

Booked 9 times today

At Panevino Ristorante in Livingston, the essence of authentic Neapolitan pizzeria shines through every detail. Celebrated for crafting pizzas that are “maybe the best tasting pizza dough I have EVER eaten in this country," Panevino's commitment to authenticity is evident. They use Caputo flour from Italy, San Marzano tomatoes, and handmade fior di latte mozzarella, ensuring each bite transports diners straight to Naples. The wood-burning oven adds a rustic charm and enhances the flavors, making their pizza a standout. With glowing reviews praising not only the atmosphere and service but specifically the pizza, Panevino is a must-visit for any pizza enthusiast looking for a slice of Italy in New Jersey.

A photo of Bivio Pizza Napoletana restaurant

2. Bivio Pizza Napoletana

4.9

Exceptional(142)

Price: Expensive

• Pizzeria • Montclair

Booked 11 times today

Bivio Pizza Napoletana in Montclair is a haven for authentic Neapolitan pizza lovers. The passionate craftsmanship is evident as each pizza is created using traditional ingredients like “00” flour from Naples, San Marzano DOP tomatoes, and fresh bufala mozzarella, all baked in a wood-burning oven. The crust, praised for its perfect balance of "crispiness, chewiness, and airiness," embodies the heart of Naples in every bite. Customers rave about the authenticity and quality, with one declaring it "the best pizza I have ever eaten in this country." Whether it's the classic Margherita or a unique creation like the Sorrento pie, Bivio delivers an outstanding culinary experience that enchants both new patrons and long-time fans alike.

A photo of Eataly Ristorante - Short Hills restaurant

3. Eataly Ristorante - Short Hills

new

3.6

Very Good(216)

Price: Moderate

• Pizzeria • Millburn

Booked 235 times today

While pizza and pasta are just the tip of the Italian iceberg, there is a reason these two culinary staples are the most beloved exports from Italy. Enjoy our seasonal selection just steps away from where our expert pasta chefs and dough-slinging pizzaioli (pizza makers) create dishes before your eyes.

A photo of La Famiglia Ristorante and Pizzeria - Maplewood restaurant

4. La Famiglia Ristorante and Pizzeria - Maplewood

4.4

Awesome(8)

Price: Moderate

• Pizzeria • Maplewood

Booked 5 times today

Step into La Famiglia Ristorante and Pizzeria in Maplewood for an unforgettable Italian dining experience that embodies the heart and soul of Italy's culinary traditions. This beloved local gem is praised for its "consistently good Italian food" made with the freshest ingredients, ensuring each dish bursts with authentic flavors. From the crispy calamari starter to the heavenly tiramisu, every item on the menu receives rave reviews. Guests consistently highlight the friendly service and cozy ambiance, with one diner noting, "The Italian food here is excellent... and the atmosphere and the music were great." Whether it's the delicious pizza with "thin and crunchy" crust or the exquisite pasta dishes like the mushroom ravioli, La Famiglia delivers a slice of Italy right in Maplewood. With accolades like "best pizza in town" and "the most delicious chicken francese I’ve ever eaten," it's clear why patrons eagerly return, making La Famiglia a must-visit for anyone seeking a genuine Italian feast.

5. Matta Donna

4.4

Awesome(55)

Price: Moderate

• Pizzeria • Boonton

Matta Donna is an Italian restaurant and pizzeria in a casual yet elegant atmosphere featuring fresh salads, seafood, pasta dishes, steaks, pizzas and other unique offerings. Owner operated for 5 years.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Best Pizzerias in West Caldwell

Price

Regions

Areas

Dining Options

Seating options

Accessibility

5 restaurants available nearby

1. Panevino Ristorante

2. Bivio Pizza Napoletana

3. Eataly Ristorante - Short Hills

4. La Famiglia Ristorante and Pizzeria - Maplewood

5. Matta Donna

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable