Best Prime Rib Restaurants in South Indy

12 restaurants available nearby

1. The Fountain Room

4.6

Exceptional(1161)

Price: Expensive

• Prime rib • Mass Ave

Booked 71 times today

Nestled in the vibrant Mass Ave neighborhood of Indianapolis, The Fountain Room redefines the steakhouse experience with its unique Supper Club ambiance and exceptional cuisine. Named one of the '50 Most Beautiful Restaurants in America' by Open Table and People Magazine, this gem offers more than just a meal; it delivers an unforgettable dining adventure. Patrons rave about the "perfection" of the prime rib and the "delicious" steak options, emphasizing both the quality and flavor. The decor, reminiscent of a glamorous era with velvet banquettes and glowing chandeliers, complements the sumptuous meals, making every visit a lavish indulgence. As one diner put it, "This place was like a modern Great Gatsby!" making The Fountain Room a must-visit destination for those seeking a top-tier steakhouse experience in Indianapolis.

A photo of St. Elmo Steak House restaurant

2. St. Elmo Steak House

4.8

Exceptional(21043)

Price: Expensive

• Prime rib • Downtown Indy

Booked 168 times today

St. Elmo Steak House in downtown Indianapolis has been a beacon of steak excellence since 1902, captivating diners with its USDA Prime Steaks that have been described as "one of the best steaks ever." A patron’s glowing review, “Great steak, 1 of the best dry-aged steaks I’ve ever had. Price was equal to the quality, you get what you pay for,” underscores the restaurant's commitment to quality and authenticity in every dish. Celebrated for more than just its food, the atmosphere at St. Elmo's provides a perfect backdrop for any occasion, whether it's a milestone birthday or just an evening out. Steaks are cooked to perfection, and the experience is often highlighted by their legendary shrimp cocktail, praised as a “must-try.” St. Elmo Steak House is truly a gem in Indianapolis, consistently providing a spectacular dining experience that leaves guests planning their next visit.

A photo of Harry & Izzy's - Downtown restaurant

3. Harry & Izzy's - Downtown

4.7

Exceptional(9619)

Price: Moderate

• Prime rib • Downtown Indy

Booked 108 times today

At Harry & Izzy's in downtown Indianapolis, seafood lovers are in for a treat with dishes that consistently garner glowing reviews. Known for their famous St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail, the restaurant delivers on both quality and taste, making each seafood dish a must-try. Diners rave about the "best scallops" and the shrimp cocktail that "LOVE" stands out as a highlight of their dining experience. Nestled in a setting that combines sophistication with comfort, Harry & Izzy's not only offers a vibrant atmosphere but also ensures each meal is crafted to perfection. As one reviewer put it, this place is where you can enjoy "phenomenal" seafood that truly "lived up to what was advertised," making it a top destination for seafood enthusiasts visiting Indianapolis.

4. Commission Row

4.8

Exceptional(535)

Price: Very Expensive

• Prime rib • Downtown Indy

Booked 55 times today

Commission Row in Downtown Indy, Indianapolis, offers a stellar Speakeasy experience beneath its vibrant dining area, known as Mel's. This hidden gem provides an authentic Speakeasy vibe where quality and ambiance meet. Guests rave about the “outstanding food choices” and the “great atmosphere,” making it the go-to spot for pre or post-event gatherings. The expertise of the staff enhances the experience, with patrons noting that the service is “impeccable” and the cocktails are “simply the best!” Mel's at Commission Row truly captures the essence of the Speakeasy tradition with a modern twist, making every visit memorable.

A photo of Harry & Izzy's - Northside restaurant

5. Harry & Izzy's - Northside

4.7

Exceptional(7179)

Price: Moderate

• Prime rib • Castleton / Keystone Crossings

Booked 103 times today

At Harry & Izzy's - Northside, located in the vibrant Castleton / Keystone Crossings area of Indianapolis, seafood aficionados are in for a real treat. Known for its upscale ambiance and top-tier customer service, this independent American Grill excels in delivering exceptional seafood dishes alongside its classic offerings. Diners rave about the "spicy but essential" shrimp cocktail and the "cheesy, buttery" lobster Mac and Cheese, highlighting the freshness and quality of the seafood served. The restaurant's dedication to quality is apparent, with one review proclaiming the seafood as "always really good." Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply indulging in a delicious meal, Harry & Izzy's commitment to excellence makes it a standout destination for seafood lovers.

A photo of Weber Grill - Indianapolis restaurant

6. Weber Grill - Indianapolis

4.5

Awesome(5900)

Price: Moderate

• Prime rib • Downtown Indy

Booked 34 times today

At Weber Grill in Downtown Indianapolis, the art of authentic barbecue is celebrated with a passion that's palpable from the first smoky bite. This restaurant, rooted in over fifty years of grilling mastery, showcases its barbecue prowess by cooking everything on genuine Weber charcoal kettles. Patrons rave about the "succulent pork chops" and the "flavorfully tender steak," which highlight the high-quality, well-seasoned meats that keep the local and visiting diners coming back for more. The ambience is perfect for those who appreciate interactive dining experiences such as cooking classes, combined with the joy of al fresco dining on the patio. Whether it’s the "amazing" grilled meatloaf or the "fall apart tender" ribs, each dish reflects a commitment to barbecue excellence. As one diner summarized, "Can't wait to come back with the family," Weber Grill stands as a beacon of barbecue delight in Indy.

A photo of Tony's of Indianapolis restaurant

7. Tony's of Indianapolis

4.8

Exceptional(2840)

Price: Expensive

• Prime rib • Downtown Indy

Booked 29 times today

At Tony’s of Indianapolis, located in the vibrant heart of Downtown Indy, seafood lovers are in for a delectable treat. Renowned for its "amazing" and "best crab cake in Indy," Tony's serves up seafood that is both fresh and exquisitely prepared. Guests consistently rave about the variety and quality, mentioning the “delicious Chilean Seabass” and the standout freshness of appetizers like Ahi Tuna and mussels. The restaurant's commitment to excellence is evident, with one diner celebrating the "fantastic selection of appetizers, especially the king crab and beef tartare," all paired with an extensive wine list. Whether it’s a special occasion or a casual dining experience, Tony's of Indianapolis is a top destination for authentic and high-quality seafood cuisine in the city.

A photo of Eddie Merlot's Prime Aged Beef & Seafood - Indianapolis restaurant

8. Eddie Merlot's Prime Aged Beef & Seafood - Indianapolis

4.5

Awesome(4600)

Price: Very Expensive

• Prime rib • Castleton / Keystone Crossings

Booked 41 times today

At Eddie Merlot's Prime Aged Beef & Seafood in Indianapolis, the steak experience transcends the ordinary, elevating it to a culinary art form. Celebrating over 20 years of excellence, this restaurant is not just about dining; it’s an homage to the love of finely aged beef. Each steak is a masterpiece, hand-cut and seasoned to perfection, reflecting the meticulous care that goes into selecting pieces with optimal marbling and texture. Patrons rave about the "melt in your mouth" filet and consistently superb service, with comments like the steak was "butter tender and flavorful." It's this relentless commitment to quality that makes Eddie Merlot's a beacon for steak connoisseurs seeking the pinnacle of prime-aged beef in a warm, inviting atmosphere.

9. Skyline Club

4.4

Awesome(776)

Price: Very Expensive

• Prime rib • Downtown Indy

Booked 4 times today

Located in the heart of Downtown Indianapolis, Skyline Club is renowned for its exceptional Bar / Lounge / Bottle Service. Offering stunning panoramic views of the city from its lofty perch, this venue combines a chic ambiance with a top-tier beverage selection. Patrons consistently rave about the "amazing views" and "good liquor selection," making it the ideal spot for a stylish evening out. Whether it’s for a romantic date or a high-profile business meeting, Skyline Club delivers an atmosphere that’s both "elegant and welcoming." Reviews often highlight the attentive service and the luxurious vibe, with one guest noting, "If you want a high-class experience, this is your place!" This club is a must-visit for anyone looking to enjoy a sophisticated night out in Indianapolis.

A photo of Firebirds Wood Fired Grill - Carmel restaurant

10. Firebirds Wood Fired Grill - Carmel

4.4

Awesome(2996)

Price: Moderate

• Prime rib • Carmel / Westfield

Booked 61 times today

Firebirds Wood Fired Grill in Carmel, Indianapolis, is a top destination for Steakhouse enthusiasts seeking authenticity and top-quality cuisine. Known for its American Restaurant appeal and wood-fired steaks, Firebirds sets itself apart with a commitment to impeccable service and upscale dining without the upscale price. Patrons rave about the "perfectly cooked" steaks and the extensive menu that keeps them coming back. As one reviewer exclaimed, "The best prime rib I’ve had in a long time." With its vibrant atmosphere and consistent quality, Firebirds Wood Fired Grill is a must-visit for those in the Carmel area looking for an exceptional Steakhouse experience.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

C
Christine
San Antonio •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
A great experience. 16 oz dry aged ribeye was great to share, spinach salad was excellent and brussel sprouts were excellent. Our server Sydney was the best. There when we needed her, but gave us plenty of space to not feel overwhelmed by interruptions.
More info
St. Elmo Steak HousePrice: Expensive• Steak• Downtown Indy
•
4.8
J
JulieVIP
Indiana •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Excellent food, Addison provided excellent service! Always a treat
More info
Bonge's TavernPrice: Expensive• American• Fishers
•
4.9
P
PAMELAVIP
Indiana •7 reviews
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
The server was wonderful! Very nice and efficient. The food was delicious! The only negative was that the area where we sat was chilly.
More info
1933 Lounge by St Elmo in FishersPrice: Expensive• Steakhouse• Fishers
•
4.7

Best Prime Rib Restaurants in South Indy

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating options

Accessibility

12 restaurants available nearby

1. The Fountain Room

2. St. Elmo Steak House

3. Harry & Izzy's - Downtown

4. Commission Row

5. Harry & Izzy's - Northside

6. Weber Grill - Indianapolis

7. Tony's of Indianapolis

8. Eddie Merlot's Prime Aged Beef & Seafood - Indianapolis

9. Skyline Club

10. Firebirds Wood Fired Grill - Carmel

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable