Best Seafood Restaurants in Erie

the fall rendition of the scallops is insanely delicious, and our server knew the menu so well. had such a great experience and will be back soon x

Great service and delicious food. We were celebrating 2 birthdays and this place did not disappoint! Highly recommend Blue Island Oyster Bar if you’re looking for a nice assortment of surf and turf options. It’s a little pricey but worth it for quality seafood.

Excellent experience! The service was amazing. The server even had a business card. The food was excellent. They even had a kids menu which was very accommodating. Expensive meal, but worth every cent with the Sea Bass, Wine, and Desserts!

I missed the grilled octopus but hoping that it comes back. I'm suggesting to try a different presentation for the bread, as it's a messy moment (bread served sitting in oil). No touching any 🍷🥂 after or with that appetizer... Otherwise the dinner offerings are as good as ever.👍🏽

As always, service was exemplary. Paired with the food and drinks made for a great experience. Yes, it is pricey, but for a special occasion it is one of the best.