5 Best Sicilian Restaurants In Bay Shore

5 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore restaurant

1. Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore

4.7

Exceptional(1002)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Bay Shore

Booked 16 times today

Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore offers a delightful experience of American cuisine that truly stands out. Nestled in the heart of Bay Shore, this charming eatery is celebrated for its "consistently delicious" dishes and "generous portions" that leave diners "extremely happy with their choices." The vibrant ambiance, enhanced by live music on select nights, creates a fun and upbeat dining environment. The attentive staff and personable service add a personal touch, ensuring every guest feels at home. With standout favorites like the Chicken Piccata and Pork Chop, Butera's promises an "11 out of 10" dining experience that never disappoints.

A photo of Marys Pizza & Restaurant restaurant

2. Marys Pizza & Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(49)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • East Islip

Mary's Pizza & Restaurant in East Islip is a hidden gem for seafood lovers, offering a delightful array of authentic Italian seafood dishes that are sure to impress. Diners rave about the "fresh and very tasty" seafood, served in generous portions that leave you with leftovers to enjoy at home. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service enhance the dining experience, making it a favorite spot for family gatherings and special occasions. Whether you're indulging in a new seafood creation or savoring a classic favorite, Mary's promises a memorable culinary journey that "never disappoints," securing its place as a neighborhood gem.

A photo of Butera's Restaurant of Sayville restaurant

3. Butera's Restaurant of Sayville

4.6

Exceptional(1445)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Sayville

Booked 7 times today

Butera's Restaurant of Sayville, nestled in the charming town of Sayville, offers a delightful twist on American cuisine with its Italian-inspired menu, ensuring an unforgettable dining experience. Diners rave about the "great service, great food, great atmosphere," with a standout mention for the "family-style chicken parm" that has become a local favorite. The restaurant's ability to "make you feel welcomed" is matched by its "amazing food," ensuring that every visit is memorable. Whether you're sharing a meal with family or enjoying a cozy dinner for two, Butera's consistently delivers "delicious food and attentive staff," making it a must-visit for American cuisine lovers.

4. Emilio's

4.4

Awesome(703)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Commack

Booked 1 time today

'Emilio's is a real hometown favorite among locals who stop in for a quick slice of pizza to go, or to sit at one of the high-top tables in the dining room and enjoy freshly prepared dishes like fried calamari, eggplant rolatini, and grilled chicken parmigiana. ' -Commack Patch

5. Gino's Trattoria

new

3.5

Very Good(1)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Smithtown

Where authentic Italian flavors meet Long Island charm. Located in Smithtown, Long Island, Gino’s Trattoria is a beloved neighborhood gem known for its commitment to culinary excellence and warm hospitality.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Best Sicilian Restaurants in Bay Shore

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating options

Accessibility

5 restaurants available nearby

1. Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore

2. Marys Pizza & Restaurant

3. Butera's Restaurant of Sayville

4. Emilio's

5. Gino's Trattoria

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable