Best Steakhouses in Bayville

Lovely birthday celebration at Rothmann's Steakhouse - Rothmann's has a terrific price-fixe special on Sundays which is difficult to beat. Not smaller portions of full-priced entrées, but the same thing including appetizer/entre/dessert with lots of options. We celebrated a special birthday here and had a great booth, great service and great food. I never come away disappointed here.

We went with a party of 6. Our server was Jade. She was very professional and attentive to our table! The drinks were excellent( I had a watermelon martini). The food was delicious! We had the fried calamari, sweet chili shrimp and grilled octopus for appetizers. It was amazing! Dinner I had the 10oz filet which was cooked perfectly! The donuts with dulce de leche made for a perfect ending to our meal! We will definitely be going back!

My boyfriend and I went for our anniversary dinner and we were not disappointed. This place exceeded our expectations and then some! The service was incredible, our waiter Andy was so attentive, and thoughtful. The staff was quick, efficient and just as attentive. They knew what we needed or wanted before we could even ask. The food was insanely delicious! Definitely our new date night spot!

Dining in this restaurant is always an enjoyable experience. The food is delicious and the ambience is lovely. Our server, Eleni, was attentive and personable. Our food was prepared perfectly. The manager, Luis, checked on the tables to inquire if all the customers were satisfied. Our valet, Lawrence, cordially greeted us upon entry and did not keep us waiting for our vehicle. We highly recommend this establishment.

From the moment we stepped into Opus, we were enveloped in an aura of warmth and sophistication. The ambiance was elegant and lively, the decor was modern and tasteful - just an overall beautiful vibe. But the true stars of the show were the service and the food. Our server, Juan, was incredibly attentive and knowledgeable. They guided us through the menu, offering insightful recommendations tailored to our preferences, as well as their specials, and catered to our allergy restrictions. Their service was seamless, anticipating our needs before we even had to ask. And then came the food. Each dish was a masterpiece of culinary artistry. The seafood tower was plentiful - filled with king crab legs, lobster, oysters, and shrimp. The sushi was truly something else - we enjoyed an assortment of rolls. And let's not forget the crème brûlée donuts– heavenly. The perfect ending. Opus a true gem. I feel that Opus is underrated when comparing to the other Scotto restaurants, this location is my absolute favorite. The combination of exceptional service, exquisite cuisine, and a captivating ambiance created an unforgettable dining experience for my family and I. We highly recommend it to anyone seeking a truly memorable meal. Thank you to our server Juan and Tim the manager who made sure we were happy from beginning to end. We will be back!