Best Steakhouses in Fisher Island

Great dinner outside. It was an outstanding experience. Attentive service by everyone.

I hate to say it, but the food here was average and uninspired. I wanted a great steak, so I ordered the tomahawk special med rare and it came out rare. After they corrected that, the steak was good, but not great. I am from NY and eat at Gallaghers and Del Friscos and it just wasn’t up to what I was hoping I would get. The fries and string beans were cooked well, but for $16 per side, I expected something special and the recipes used were just meh. The service and atmosphere were excellent, except for the fact the place was empty while I was there, just at the beginning of dinner hour on a Tuesday. I would like to shout out Amanda for the excellent service she provided.

Another excellent meal. The sliced filet was delicious as the 10 oz filet. Pleasure to dine there.

Atmosphere was great. The service was perfect. The food was fabulous! Mash potatoes with truffles was AMAZING

I have been waiting to go here for a few months now, it did does disppapoint! Very cool vibe, service was outstanding! The food was incredible and the best steak i have had. Very expensive place but if you celebrating an occasion, it is definitely worth it!