Best Steakhouses in Lumberville

Cooper, our friendly and knowledgeable server, helped make our dinner a memorable experience. with picturesque winter view of the Delaware. We shared the “perfect duo”, filet and lobster tail. Added shrimp and mushroom/onion. Everything well prepared and delicious dipped in wine reduction sauce.

Excellent service by Melvin. We were intrigued by some of the specials but find hard to deviate from the date night menu, which is an excellent value with a lot of choices. We shared the honey crisp salad to start. This is split in the kitchen and that makes a difference. The half portion is large with the cheese and pecans is wonderful. We also ordered the calamari, which is delicious but took most of it home as the portion is huge. Entrees were the king salmon, which was expertly prepared, and the filet mignon. There is an up charge but again the portion is large and also came home! We shared the apple tart for dessert which came with ice cream but took the other home. So many different tastes…a really nice evening.

This was my first holiday dining out since I lost my mother who was my every holiday expert cook and host. At Sullivan’s Steakhouse, I received outstanding service, and I had an excellent dining experience. My server Maurice was thorough and provided me and my guest with a superior level of personalized service. The food was prepared as requested, seasoned well and five stars delicious. The atmosphere was wonderful. It was at a good holiday celebration noise level. And the few children I observed as present were well mannered and dressed nicely for the occasion. The manager Michael Pons Jr. was hands-on and very attentive to his restaurant guests. He made me feel like a valued customer. I left Sullivan’s Steakhouse feeling fantastic, so much so, that before turning in that night I made reservations for New Year’s Eve dining.

Great place to celebrate holidays Second year in a row we went there for Xmas Eve.

Once again a delicious meal and probably the best service we've ever had there! Sarah was absolutely AMAZING and so very considerate as we were celebrating my husband's birthday! She definitely went the extra mile to make EVERYTHING absolutely perfect! Totally enjoyed our experience on an extremely busy night December 23rd! Thank you for all the efforts!