Best Steakhouses in Fishers Island

Everything was outstanding! We had a 7 o'clock reservation and got seated at 7:20, but it was a Valentine's Day on a Friday, so that was to be expected. They brought champagne to the ladies while we waited, which was a great touch of hospitality. The wait staff were knowledgeable, attentive, and friendly. Our food came out quickly, was prepared properly, and tasted delicious. Our runner Edmund was another highlight; he was sociable and polite, and not intrusive or overbearing. If I had to offer a critique, I'd say the mocktails were good but seemed a little uninspired. We'll definitely be back! And glad to see sushi back on the menu!

Fantastic experience for a Valentines Day Dinner. Girlfriend had the filet. I had the Bone in Strip Steak. Both of us were in agreement that they were the best steaks we’ve had yet. Drinks were fantastic (Bulliet Old Fashioned and Tito’s Espresso Martini). Service was top notch. Will definitely be returning!

Our service was first rate, our waiter had a great attitude and was well informed with the menu and prep. Food was as usual well prepared and delicious.

Came for my wife’s Birthday and the place was Beautiful oh my goodness I mean perfect haven’t seen a restaurant this nice in a long time , the waitress and waiter were on point and made us hungry when he went over the menu . However I have to go back my steak was great but wish my veggies were a little more tasteful the Mash potatoes were really good but I must go back to Try something different

I went to an early Valentine’s Day dinner with friends, and it was truly a memorable experience. The atmosphere was enchanting, with soft candlelight flickering on the tables and gentle music playing in the background. Each dish we savored was a culinary masterpiece, beautifully presented and bursting with flavor. The highlight of the evening was definitely the exceptional service provided by the manager, Cliff, who went above and beyond to ensure we had a fantastic time. His warm hospitality and attention to detail made the night even more special.