Best Steakhouses in Fishers Island

We had a great dining experience here. Stepping into the restaurant felt like an upscale venue in Manhattan but with a lot more space. The staff was so pleasant and warm. Our server’s Henry and Filipe were simply incredible. They were a great team and made sure we were well taken care of. They were so accommodating to our young kids and guided us through the menu with ease. Which brings me to the food. Delicious!!!! I usually take pics of my food but it was so good I couldn’t wait to dive in. I will definitely be returning here.

We had an amazing experience. Our servers Gaby and Stephanie were exceptional and very professional. Their knowledge of the food and drinks were impeccable. They made our Christmas Eve dining experience very memorable and enjoyable.

Excellent choice for Christmas Eve. Great dinner. Delicious choices. Service was amazing too. Food was super. Highly recommend.

Excellent dinner tonight to celebrate Christmas. Our main server, Jory, was outstanding. So was his teammate - just can't remember her name. The team was both attentive when needed and stayed away when they weren't needed to give us space. Group of 5 - we all had steaks - 3 orders of filet mignon, one bone in filet and a bone in ribeye. Sides and steaks arrived hot - cooked just as everyone wanted. We had a few appetizers - burrata, bacon and carpaccio. Not much room for dessert - except for a soufflé. Outstanding meal - great service and excellent food. Will return after the new year - a lot of interesting items on the menu for us to explore.

Been here at least a half dozen times. I've brought my family over for lunch & diner & have also held large events for 25+ people. Sean and his crew offer consistent top notch service. The pasta and chicken dishes are very good. This place keeps me going to the gym. I can't get enough.