Best Traditional Mexican Restaurants in Theater District

20 restaurants available nearby

1. Toloache-Midtown

4.7

Exceptional(7641)

Price: Moderate

• Traditional mexican • Theater District

Booked 46 times today

Toloache-Midtown, located in the vibrant heart of New York's Theater District, is a gem for contemporary Mexican cuisine. Chef-owner Julian Medina's creative mastery shines in dishes infused with seasonal ingredients and an impressive variety of chilies. Guests rave about the "best ceviche" and "delicious, authentic & perfectly seasoned" meals, highlighting favorites like the lobster tacos and the unique pumpkin black truffle creamy rice. The guacamole and ceviche bar, alongside a wood-burning oven, adds a special touch to the dining experience. Reviews consistently praise the "outstanding food and service," making Toloache-Midtown a must-visit for a spellbinding Mexican culinary adventure.

2. Sinigual - NY

4.4

Awesome(2775)

Price: Moderate

• Traditional mexican • Midtown East

Booked 38 times today

Sinigual, a Manhattan favorite since 2008, offers modern Mexican cuisine just three blocks from Grand Central. Indulge in farm-fresh dishes like our tableside guacamole and handcrafted margaritas, all served in the heart of NYC. Join us for our Weekday Happy Hour, Taco Tuesday, & Weekend Brunch with Tableside Mimosa Buckets.

A photo of Toloache - Upper East Side restaurant

3. Toloache - Upper East Side

4.8

Exceptional(1626)

Price: Expensive

• Traditional mexican • Upper East Side

Booked 20 times today

Toloache, located in the Upper East Side, New York, is a gem for lovers of Contemporary Mexican cuisine. As exquisitely noted by one patron, Toloache is "a Mexican restaurant a whole level above the usual," where Chef Julian Medina dazzles with his innovative use of natural ingredients and an array of chilies. The menu, featuring standout items like shredded duck with tamarind sauce and the unique quinoa truffle paella, has been consistently praised for its "explosion of flavors." Customers rave about the "melt-in-your-mouth" tacos and the enchanting Toloache crunch cake with chocolate pop rocks, enhancing every dining experience with a touch of magic. With its cozy and elegant ambiance, Toloache promises not just a meal, but a delightful culinary adventure in the heart of New York.

A photo of Dos Caminos - Lexington Avenue restaurant

4. Dos Caminos - Lexington Avenue

4.0

Excellent(106)

Price: Moderate

• Traditional mexican • Midtown East

Booked 6 times today

Welcome to Dos Caminos Lexington! Join the fiesta at one of New York City’s original Mexican restaurants! Dos Caminos features an expanded menu of authentic Mexican dishes as well as an extensive selection of premium tequilas and delicious, innovative cocktails. Experience the multi-regional modern cuisine for lunch, dinner and weekend brunch.

5. La Palapa

4.6

Exceptional(867)

Price: Moderate

• Traditional mexican • East Village

Booked 4 times today

La Palapa, nestled in the vibrant East Village of New York, is renowned for its authentic Mexican cuisine, crafting "Mexico City style" tacos and quesadillas that transport your taste buds straight to the heart of Mexico. Patrons rave about the "amazing salsas" and the "best authentic food" in the city, highlighting dishes like Tacos al Pastor and Mole Negro Oaxaqueno. The restaurant's atmosphere is described as warm and friendly, making it a neighborhood favorite for nearly 20 years. Their award-winning Margaritas, made with fresh juices and a unique chile-piquin salted rim, are a must-try. As one reviewer puts it, La Palapa is "still so consistent and delicious," making it the go-to spot for genuine Mexican flavors in NYC.

6. Casa Bond

4.7

Exceptional(93)

Price: Expensive

• Traditional mexican • NoHo

Booked 1 time today

Casa Bond offers a vibrant dining experience, blending creative, modern Mexican cuisine with a chic, Bohemian atmosphere. Named one of "New York's Best New Restaurants of 2023" by the Financial Times, we’re known for standout dishes like Aguachile and Gobernador Tacos. Join us for an unforgettable meal that captures the essence of authentic Mexican flavors with a contemporary twist. Perfect for those seeking top-notch service, exceptional food, and a lively, artistic ambiance.

A photo of Caliente Cab Mexican Cafe restaurant

7. Caliente Cab Mexican Cafe

4.8

Exceptional(442)

Price: Moderate

• Traditional mexican • West Village

Booked 9 times today

Caliente Cab Mexican Café is open for lunch, dinner and late-night meals. It also offers a weekend brunch featuring dishes like Mexican French toast and grilled eggs, as well as morning cocktails. Throughout the day, you can order from a list of traditional Mexican items such as fajitas, tacos and burritos. To complement your meal, add flavor to your dish with the freshly made salsa and guacamole.Caliente Cab Mexican Café provides a casual, bar-like environment. Along with a festive décor, it offers an outdoor patio space for dining with family or enjoying drinks like margaritas, mojitos or sangria with friends.We also do parties and catering for all occasions!

8. Mole West Village

4.4

Awesome(82)

Price: Moderate

• Traditional mexican • West Village

At Móle West Village in the heart of New York's bustling West Village, you'll experience Tex-Mex cuisine that dazzles and delights. Renowned for its authentic and sumptuous dishes, Móle offers everything from "Mexico City style shrimp ceviche that was to die for" to "superb brisket tacos" that keep patrons coming back. The "irresistible tableside guacamole," prepared fresh right before your eyes, embodies the restaurant's commitment to freshness and quality. Not just a treat for the palate, Móle features a cozy atmosphere and a "terrific outdoor seating" area, perfect for enjoying up to 125 varieties of tequila. According to one glowing review, "The cocktails are fire - perfectly crafted," making Móle not just a meal but an experience. A must-visit for anyone craving genuine Tex-Mex in NYC!

A photo of Orale Mexican Kitchen - Jersey City restaurant

9. Orale Mexican Kitchen - Jersey City

4.7

Exceptional(744)

Price: Expensive

• Traditional mexican • Jersey City

Booked 9 times today

ORALE MEXICAN KITCHEN IN JERSEY CITYLocated in the heart of Downtown Jersey City, Orale is the perfect spot for Happy Hour, Taco Tuesday, Boozy Brunch, or an eventful Cinco de Mayo.Enjoy Authentic Food with a Twist at Our Mexican Restaurant in Jersey CityWhen you’re looking for a Modern Mexican food experience, you can get what you’re looking for at Orale Mexican Kitchen. We are proud to be one of the best Mexican restaurants in Jersey City, providing our customers with authentic food with a unique twist. Rather than limiting the menu at our local restaurant to traditional meals for dinner like tacos, burritos, and other options, we also offer a fantastic Mexican brunch that will keep you coming back for more. You’ll come for the food and stay for the fun atmosphere our Mexican kitchen provides, giving you the high-quality restaurant service you deserve.

10. Tortaria

4.0

Excellent(107)

Price: Moderate

• Traditional mexican • Union Square

Booked 2 times today

Tortaria, in the Union Square neighborhood of New York City, crafts specialty Mexican sandwiches and celebrates tequila cocktails in its bright and modern eatery outfitted with retro knickknacks. Tortaria’s main bill of fare is tortas, traditional Mexican sandwiches on fresh baked, ciabatta-like bread. Some of the most popular varieties include the slow-roasted pulled pork with Chihuahua cheese, avocado, roasted chipotle peppers and pickled onion, the panko-crusted chicken Milanesa with spicy black beans, Oaxaca cheese, chipotle mayo and cilantro and the torta beef burger, piled high with mozzarella, piloncillo tomatoes, jalapenos and chipotle mayo. Rolled and deep fried taquitos are the other staple at Tortaria, with flavors such as carne asada with tomatillo salsa and mahi lime tacos with citrus jalapeno remoulade being crisp and fresh choices.For a unique house cocktail, enjoy the house margarita with Conquistador tequila, triple sec, agave, and lime.

How is content generated

Discover best Traditional Mexican restaurants in Theater District

Discover the vibrant flavors of traditional Mexican cuisine right in the heart of New York City's Theater District, Manhattan. This bustling area, known for its dynamic dining scene, offers a variety of restaurants that specialize in authentic Mexican dishes, from tantalizing tacos to savory enchiladas and beyond. Each restaurant captures the essence of Mexican culinary traditions, utilizing fresh ingredients and classic cooking techniques to deliver mouth-watering meals in a lively and welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're seeking a casual dining experience or a more sophisticated evening out, the Theater District has a Mexican restaurant to satisfy every palate and occasion. Patrons can expect not only delicious food but also an engaging ambiance that often includes vibrant decor and sometimes live music, making each meal a memorable event. Explore the rich tastes and festive spirit of Mexico, all conveniently located near the iconic theaters and bustling streets of Manhattan.

Explore OpenTable

Theater District

Traditional mexican

Best Traditional Mexican Restaurants in Theater District

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating options

Accessibility

20 restaurants available nearby

1. Toloache-Midtown

2. Sinigual - NY

3. Toloache - Upper East Side

4. Dos Caminos - Lexington Avenue

5. La Palapa

6. Casa Bond

7. Caliente Cab Mexican Cafe

8. Mole West Village

9. Orale Mexican Kitchen - Jersey City

10. Tortaria

Discover best Traditional Mexican restaurants in Theater District

Explore OpenTable