Best Authentic Restaurants in Water Mill

The EliaEstiatorio From the moment we walk in, you’re greeted by a warm, inviting ambiance, complete with cozy lighting and a tasteful modern-meets-rustic decor. The menu is a delightful mix of traditional favorites and innovative dishes, catering to a range of palates. We started with the feta cheese which was rich, creamy, and perfect amount. For the main course, we opted for their signature dish short rip with orzo Cooked to perfection, each bite was tender, flavorful, and complemented beautifully by the Brussels sprout and lemon potatoes Dessert chef Παύλος specialty apple pie and the ice cream was pure heaven. Service was impeccable throughout the evening. The staff was attentive without being intrusive, knowledgeable about the menu, and genuinely seemed to enjoy creating a wonderful dining experience. Prices are on the higher side, but the quality of food and service justifies the expense. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just indulging in a night out, The Elia Estiatorio worth a visit. I’ll definitely be returning soon!

I spent Thanksgiving at The Palm for a table of 8. Some had the pre fixe and others ordered off the menu. The ambiance is fantastic and the manager Chris was exceptional accommodating of our numerous reservation adjustments. Food was lovely and very cozy warm vibes. 10/10 dining experience especially for a larger party on a holiday

My husband and I dined at Calissa for the first time this past Sunday. The restaurant was nice and warm when we came in from the cold. We were greeted warmly. The restaurant is beautiful and inviting. We ordered from the prix fixe menu. There were many great choices offered and the food was plentiful and excellently prepared. The staff were very attentive. Overall, we had a great experience and will definitely come back.

R'AIRE Is a rare find in the Hamptons. Delicious, quality, locally sourced food and a varied menu served in a calm, understated setting. Our favorite!!!!

We will miss Boa until they return in May! Have a good winter!