Best Date Night Restaurants in Paia

Outstanding views of the Plantation golf course as well as the beach with whales jumping every five seconds to remind us how nature is so powerful! Pair that with a great holiday menu (3 courses) with plenty of options! I had the crab cakes and my husband a salad to start. Salad was light and fresh and crab cakes were flavorful and crispy. For mains, my husband had the rack of lamb and I had the macadamia nut crusted mahi. Both were delicious and came in big servings. Dessert, was the cherry of the ice cream! The best pineapple upside down cake!!! Our waiter was always on top of everything and was super sweet! We will definitely come back!

Amazing! Their charcoal cooked fish was amazing. Best fish we ever had. It’s pricey but it’s definitely enough food for 2-4 people and comes with 2 sides. My wife and I had enough leftover and added it to Caesar salads by the pool the next day. Definitely recommend getting the fish. The Maui onion dip was amazing too and could eat it all day long.

Outstanding food and service. We ate breakfast with Andy as our server and the was amazing so we decided to go back for dinner. Fresh ingredients, amazing service and super location. We will return!

We celebrated our 1st anniversary @ Mala and returned for our 8th. The view is amazing, especially at sunset. Every dish we’ve had has been delicious but I think the seared scallops with Parmesan risotto is hard to beat! Carlos was a great server - just the right balance of attentiveness & space for us to enjoy our special date night. Mala was the only reservation I made prior to our trip to ensure we didn’t miss out. Highly recommended!

From the moment we stepped into Humuhumunukunukuāpuaʻa, we were blown away by the ambiance, service, and, most importantly, the food! Every dish was a masterpiece, beautifully presented and bursting with flavor. Even our two young children (3 and 6) loved their Starburst drinks and teriyaki steaks. A special shoutout to our server, Bryan, who truly elevated our evening. His knowledge of the menu, attentive service, and friendly demeanor made us feel so well taken care of. We left completely satisfied and can’t wait to return. Highly recommend Humuhumunukunukuāpuaʻa to anyone looking for an unforgettable dining experience.