Best Family Style Restaurants in Fisher Island

The service was attentive and well informed on the menu. I was dining with my children which enjoyed the variety and care into the dishes. Overall it was an enjoyable experience. The one area I’d provide constructive feedback is to explore the wagyu ribeye quality control. We had two at the table and they were both tough/chewy in relation to the expectations. It would also be helpful to understand origin on the menu, as I’ll assume this was domestic based on the items noted above. The wagyu hanger steak was top notch and above expectations as were the other dishes. I was especially pleased with how the service treated my teenage kids, helping them through the menu and presentation.

We were four people celebrating my birthday. My waiter was Maykel and he was fantastic. Everyone who works there has a great attitude, all willing to help the other, which is very unusual for a restaurant like this. It was a pleasant surprise and made my birthday super special. The food is meticulously done in such nice taste. Everything has a beautiful presentation. This is not the restaurant where you come starving because the portions are small but delicious. Every bite is an explosion of taste in your mouth. We ordered 12 different appetizers all amazing. The most impressive thing about this restaurant was the service and the energy inside. It’s just a great ambience. There was a fire dancer. The mood is fun. Thank you so much for making my birthday special.

Simona and Mercedes took great care of us. I recommend the four course tasting menu with wine pairing. Every dish was unique, flavorful, healthy, decadent, and an experience all in itself. The chef knows what they are doing. This is a foodie paradise. We were counting, or trying to, and I think we tried about 12 new dishes that we had never had with this pairing. To top it off, we sat outside and the setting is absolutely beautiful and relaxing. The chairs are very wide and comfortable, and the foliage makes you feel like you’re in another country. thank you for the handwritten card for my mother’s birthday. I forgot to grab it so I will come back for it tonight. Well. We might as well have dinner too!

Everything was perfect from our server, Kfir, to the food. Our 3rd or 3rh time dining there and the chef never fails to impress us with his perfectly seasoned food.

🌟 Amazing Dining Experience at Prime Italian! 🌟 We had the absolute pleasure of dining at Prime Italian, and it was nothing short of spectacular! 🍽️✨ The food? Outstanding. Every dish was perfectly prepared, full of flavor, and beautifully presented. From the appetizers to the desserts, it was a culinary masterpiece. 🍝🍷 The atmosphere? Elegant yet inviting. The ambiance was cozy and upscale, making it perfect for a night out. The attention to detail in the decor created such a warm and classy vibe. 🕯️🎶Our favorite dessert was the fried oriole cookie desert with vanilla ice cream . The service? Impeccable. The staff went above and beyond to ensure we felt welcomed and cared for. Their attentiveness and professionalism truly elevated the experience. 👏🍴 If you’re looking for a place that delivers exceptional food, service, and atmosphere, Prime Italian is the spot! #PrimeItalian #DiningExperience #FoodieHeaven #ExceptionalService #ItalianCuisine #DateNightGoals 🍷🍝✨