Best Restaurants with Private Rooms in Starlight, IN

What can I say other than WOW! We are in from Indianapolis for the weekend and wanted some seafood. Open table recommended Brendon’s Catch 23 and we decided to give it a try. We were greeted immediately and seated at our table and our server Ross greeted us within 30 seconds. I of course liked him instantly because his name is from one of my shows, Friends. Ross is incredible! He knows everything about the entire menu as well as the cocktails. He guided us to the crab in warm butter with sourdough bread for the starter and it is divine! Definitely order that! I have an obsession with Cauliflower steak and it was really good. I loved how they seasoned it with steak seasoning. It had a small warm green salad and a corn and bean side to accompany. I really liked this dish. My husband had the shrimp and grits and it was delicious. Perfectly cooked and tender shrimp but it was a lot of food! Definitely a dish that could be shared. We were given 2 corn bread muffins with a honey cinnamon butter that was the perfect accompaniment to our dishes. I ordered the Beignets for dessert and if you get anything GET THOSE! They were perfectly cooked , crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. They Came with two dipping sauces, and we’re so large we took two home! Roasted even brewed a fresh pot of decaf for me as I love coffee with my dessert. Ross was very attentive to our dining needs and really made us feel welcome. He always had a smile on his face every time I saw him and he truly went above and beyond and made our dining experience even more enjoyable. Thank you Ross for the incredible time and for making us feel like Friends!!!! We Will definitely be back and asking for Ross!  

A consistent favorite! My daughter loves to celebrate her birthday here. Recognizing the occasion, the staff contacted me and arranged for a special table upstairs (her favorite!) They even accommodated us early. Zoe was our server and made the experience so special for us. Love this place!

Pleasantly surprised by the quality of food. Everything we had was incredible. Loved that they offered smaller portions on the menu and a full variety of dishes. Seafood. Pork. Beef. Vegetarian. Service was a great, a little slow but it was a VERY busy night. Loved seeing the team effort with food being brought immediately to the tables (vs waiting on the server to bring it) and staff running drinks to tables outside their section. Will return. 5/5 stars.

We had a group of five. All meals were awesome. Service was timely and great.

I have loved every meal I've ever eaten at Seviche! This one was no different! The staff was attentive and polite, the food was incredibly good, and at the end of the meal the bill was less than I expected!! Two of us had the salmon, which surprised me with flavors I wasn't expecting... It was to die for! The steak special was loved by the guy that ordered it as were the Scallops and Skirt Steak! Cannot recommend this restaurant highly enough!