Best Restaurants for Anniversaries in Nutley

A true stakehouse. Their menu offers a diverse variety of choices. Their service is impeccable with wonderful specials to boot. A wonderful dining experience!

One If By Land is one of the most beautiful restaurants in New York, with the most exceptional service and ambience. The ambience feels special (and cozy) with subtle lighting, fresh flowers everywhere, as well as twinkling white lights and candles, and views of the garden patio. One member of our party was delayed in their arrival, and the restaurant graciously waited before beginning service, and never pressured us about the unexpected delay. The timing of every aspect of the entire evening was impeccable, with servers patiently waiting an appropriate amount of time at every stage of ordering and serving. The food was delicious with every course was prepared beautifully. We had the Beef Wellington, Rib Eye, and Halibut. For dessert, we all enjoyed chocolate soufflés and the waiters brought an extra plate of bite sized treats for a birthday we were celebrating. It was an evening we will never forget and we will undoubtedly return to One If By Land for special occasions, if we are lucky enough to secure a reservation!

Our first time back to our favorite restaurant since Chef Greg took over, and he did not disappoint. The menu is a very nice balance of some Matisse favorites with some new, wonderful creations. The staff are first rate. We will be back.

Took my daughter and her friends for her birthday. Chef and server were fun and attentive. A great time had by all and the food was delicious.

Delicious omakase in a convenient location in Hoboken. The sake based cocktail was also very tasty and fresh. All the courses were beautifully presented and the chef and staff made sure we were going at a good pace. Would return.