Best Restaurants for Quiet Conversation in Nutley

Went on Valentine's Day before the theater. didn't feel rushed, yet prompt. All the food was excellent- Grilled squid with salad , perfectly done. Lasagna- very different but very good. Shrimp risotto was out of this world; As a gluten-free dessert and one of the best-melted chocolate cakes ever. Hazelnut custard is also delicious. Overall, it was a great experience with quality food and excellent service. Will go back again

I must echo the comments of anyone who calls the alderman a hidden gem. It is truly a little oasis in the hub of Times Square with some of the best food and service I’ve had in a long while.  Everyone we encountered was professional, polite, friendly, relaxed, and service was on point at all times. A special shout out to Hersey at the bar and our server Ethan, who was just tremendous honest and very attentive, to the lovely manager, a young blonde woman whose name I forgot sorry. Had the perfectly prepared salmon and flirt steak entrees from the prix fixe menu plus ALL the other TASTY courses and they were very generous portions, very satisfying and a wonderful value. Cannot recommend this enough if you are going to a show or you just want to have an enjoyable evening dinner lunch or just a coffee from the front barista station. The ambience is warm and tasteful. Like sitting in a garden! Just terrific. You won’t be disappointed.

We absolutely loved our meal! The pre-theater dinner menu was well priced -- an excellent value for NYC and for the quantity and quality of the food. The food was absolutely supurb! And our server was professional and caring. We loved the "cool" atmosphere of the dining room. We will definitely be back.

We had a fabulous dinner at Rosie’s! I had fillet and lobster my husband had chicken cordon bleu. Both entrees were fantastic. The new Rosie’s is beautifully done. It was quiet and the service was wonderful.

Great breakfast food. Especially love the omelet with leeks and Gruyere. Excellent coffee. This was 4th or 5th time eating here. Always great.