Best Restaurants with a Fireplace in Rye

One of our favorite restaurants and worth the drive, consistently providing high quality, delicious, farm to table foods. The duck breast was the best I have ever had, and my wife said the same about her braised short rib. The appetizer, salad and dessert were great as well.

Always a fine spot with the best chowdah on the planet.

Everything was perfect, the restaurant has such a homey old time feel. All the staff was super welcoming and it had been noted on the reservation it was my wifes birthday and they all greeted her with happy birthday and the birthday card on the table was a very nice unexpected touch. The food was beyond fabulous!!!! Loved the fire place smell, and the environment was perfect, alive and folks having conversation but we could very easily have a private conversation at our table. Post dinner walking the Strawberry Bank grounds all lit up for the holidays was an amazing fun bonus.

Excellent service, food was perfection. My haddock dish was perfect, along with friends steak dinner and another’s chicken dish. More than happy visiting Galley Hatch as always!

The restaurant seemed to cater to an older crowd which wasn't bad since I am in my sixties. We were seated at a table that was very wet. When given a drink minute, there were no prices listed. When I asked the server, he didn't know how much they were and said they varied in price. The food was very good with large portions. The price was average-high being at the beach and in a resort hotel. The fisherman's platter was $28. Enjoyed the DJ and dancing in the rear of the restaurant starting at 8pm. All in all we had a good time and would go back.