Best Restaurants with a Fireplace in Islip

The Lake House was wonderful! The food and wine were delicious and everything arrived to the table in a timely manner, without the feeling of being rushed. The service was attentive but not intrusive. Overall an amazing experience!

The staff is very friendly and professional. The calamari is crispy & delicious. The decor is festive.

Food and service was fabulous as always. Steaks cooked perfectly, restaurant festive and the banana cream pie for dessert was amazing.

Salt & Barrell is a combination of great food and great service with an energetic vibe. Whether it's the host, the manager or the server, everyone who works there is super friendly, and very accommodating. The menu evolves, so going regularly doesn't create monotony. The drinks are phenomenal, and their whiskey menu (The Bible) is extensive. They could use a little improvement on the wine list (which is very small, with not a lot of good options), but you can easily get past this. Salt & Barrell is by far one of the best restaurants in Bay Shore, and worth a visit.

Very cozy location with excellent staff. The food was perfect and the drinks were better.