Best Restaurants with a Fireplace in Sag Harbor

Phenomenal. Pick the tavern if you want a warm cozy fireside dinner. Go here. Do this. And stay here the rooms looked adorable. The food oh my goodness was incredible. Oysters, red and green salad, lobster and the ribs, all absolutely delicious. The maple cornbread that comes with the ribs, there are no words. Oh and if you want to smell the most incredible apple cobbler order it and the cappuccino. Ohhhh and the wine. It was all amazing. Chef is top tier.

Amazing service and food . Attention to detail and went above and beyond will be going back !

What a wonderful evening and way to spend with someone special. The food was delicious, the drinks were a marvel and even the other guests were a pleasure to be in the company of. That said the staff had a cohesive, calm elevated demeanor that set the stage a memorable night. I’ll be bringing my family back for a breakfast so they can experience its charm as well.

We had an absolutely fantastic experience at Halyard. From the moment we arrived, the service was warm, friendly, and incredibly attentive, making us feel truly welcomed. The food was just as impressive—each dish was thoughtfully prepared and bursting with flavor. We started with the tuna tartare and the calamari, which came with a delightful surprise—perfectly blistered shishito peppers that added just the right amount of heat. For our main course, the halibut was cooked to perfection, and the Brussels sprouts were crispy and full of flavor. The cheese-laced mashed potatoes were an indulgent, creamy dream. Dessert was an espresso-infused crème brûlée that was both unexpected and absolutely delicious. Halyard exceeded our expectations in every way.

Thoroughly enjoyable and food was top notch as always - we will be going back again