Best Historic Restaurants in Hampton Bays

We had a fantastic evening at Waterlot! It is reminiscent of the old Waterlot which really made me feel warm - the food was immaculate the service was amazing! There was never a moment where someone wasn’t there when we needed something! We are planning our next date night there as we speak! Thanks for making our anniversary celebration and first date night of the year a special one!

Tweeds always delivers. This place is spectacular! So great to have such a historical restaurant on Long Island consistently delivering outstanding food and service.

Elegant atmosphere, seasonally prepared curated cocktails and delicious farm to table dining all done with outstanding service , Jedediah Hawkins has it all. Highly recommend

Always hesitate to leave a positive review because it only means a favorite eating place will get even more jammed. That said, we like coming to the Public House. The atmosphere is relaxed, the food is plentiful and generally quite delicious. Julia our server was especially friendly, but without intruding. After taking our orders, she checked back several times to see if everything was ok and/or if we needed anything more. (On other occasions, Marsha has been great, but she does not work on Saturdays). The food was good. New England Clam Chowder. French Onion Soup & Chopped Wedge Salads were delicious. Wings were good; Chicken Picatta less so because the lemon sauce with capers tasted definitely like an add on instead of being infused into the chicken. All in all, however, it was another good evening... and a good dinner. We'll be back!