Best Historic Restaurants in Richmond Hill

Get an afternoon reservation. Get the burger. That simple. Delicious. Would and probably will come back if I’m in New York and this is in the line of the things I’m going to see that day.

Excellent experience. The Roederer champagne by the glass for our apéritif was outstanding. Our petite filet mignon steaks were perfectly cooked, and the sides of fries and asparagus were also very good. The Béarnaise sauce accompanying the steaks was unfortunately very poor, too thin in consistency and almost complete lacking in any suggestion of tarragon, the signature ingredient of this sauce. As promised by our excellent server, Eddie, the Butterscotch Brûlée dessert was dreamy. All in all, a most enjoyable dining experience!

Our experience was incredible. We got a private dining room which they said was just by luck that we got it. We loved it. Our waiter, Sean, was super. He was very attentive to us. Checked on us frequently. I had the chicken pot pie and I loved it. My sister had the oysters and a Scottish egg and she really liked her food. Highly recommend.

Tucked into Central Park, Tavern on the Green was the perfect holiday experience to round out our Christmas in NYC trip! Cozy and festive decor paired with impeccable service and delectable food makes this a “must try” for anyone looking to soak in the magic that is Christmas in New York! I highly recommend the honey roasted fig appetizer and the pan seared scallop entree.

Service was excellent. We thoroughly enjoyed a large house salad, chicken sandwich and the best Goodfellas burger with delicious French fries. The Wise Guy cocktail is always my favorite and the beer choices are excellent. We can't wait to go back. It is a great place to meet up with friends or come to see one of their special presentations.