Best Historic Restaurants in Rutherford

Wonderful dining experience from beginning to end in an idyllic atmosphere. Will definitely be back there again next time I’m in NYC.

Beautiful ambiance. Food was good and service was lovely. Not quite worth the money for wine and food. Would only go back for a cocktail purely for the ambiance.

Super cute little restaurant with a friendly and efficient staff. The Emmy Double Stack burger is a good as you’ve heard it is. Get it. Waffle fries were great as well. We shared the burger and a pizza between 3 people and were stuffed. The pizza is good - Detroit style - but I’ve had better. Otherwise a really great experience!

Amazing view across to Manhattan, whilst eating some incredible tasting but well priced food. A rarity in NY these days. Waiter was very attentive and helpful, would highly recommend.

I made an reservation and arrived about 15 minutes early which allowed us to enjoy some time at the bar. The bar staff were absolutely amazing! Unfortunately, we waited 43 minutes past our scheduled time before I mentioned to the bartender that no one had come to seat us. The young lady who checked us in seemed a bit flustered at first but eventually realized she hadn’t come to get us when the table was ready. After being seated, it took a while for someone to come over for our drink orders. Once we finally got our drinks, there was another wait to place our food order. The food was fantastic, but the service needs improvement—particularly with a more reliable hostess and servers. The bar staff are doing a great job, but they can’t handle everything on their own. Overall, despite these few hiccups, our experience was fantastic, and I would definitely return!