Best Historic Restaurants in St. Augustine

We or a table of five and celebrating a birthday. The food was fantastic. Everything was so delicious and harmony. Our waitress was over the top. Great. Highly recommend this restaurant.

Had a wonderful experience here. Staff is friendly and personalized our experience. The steak au poivre is not to be missed - steak was cooked beautifully, sauce was flavorful and just as au poivre should be. The moules frites was a real treat as well - it’s a HUGE portion, but cooked to absolute perfection. Wine selection and pairing recommendations were on point as well. Thanks for having us and leaving such an impression on us!

The menu was filled with fun and delicious holiday cocktails. My wife and I enjoyed two specialty cocktails and both were delicious. Don’t forget the delicious food. We stopped in for a late lunch and chose a few appetizers for our meal. We shared the charcuterie board and the baked Brie, bother was amazing. The atmosphere was fun and festive for the Chrismas season. The decor was beautiful and very well done.

Fine dining has grown exponentially in St Augustine and this fabulous location in the Casa Monica has had a few hits and misses. Cordova is a hit! We’ve dine here a few times but tonight was exceptional. Our server, Martin, is wonderful, he knows the menu and was spot on with every suggestion. Lobster roll appetizer and She crab bisque are phenomenal. The steaks, filet tonight, melts in your mouth. The signature pork chop was amazing. Finished with cinnamon bread pudding. What a treat! Oh, and the convenience of valet parking. Highly recommend!!

Esteban was the best! We love Old City House and come here frequently. The food and the service cannot be beat!