Best Neighbourhood Gem Restaurants in Montauk

Amazing as usual. Tonight we had Blackened Swordfish, Lobster Cardinale, Chicken Parm Meatballs, and a PB&C Torte for dessert. Accompanied by a bottle of Sancerre, and topnotch service from Shannon made for a great evening.

Was a nice afternoon treat. They were very nice and had a small cake with candle for my birthday.

Great view to go along with excellent service and food

Each and every time we have gone to The Coast Guard House we have had an Incredible meal. Consistently excellent. My wife had a special that included shrimp, lobster and scallops in a pasta with an assortment of flavors while I had the Lobster Mac & Cheese. The Mac & Cheese was loaded with lobster and totally filled me up. My wife also had plenty of the shrimp, scallops and lobster in her dish. We went to celebrate my wife's birthday and boy did we pick a beautiful night to go as the weather was around 60 and the sky was clear while the 3/4 moon was visible in the east sky. Daylight saving proved to be to our advantage as we had a spectacular ocean to view while the sun was lowering in the west leaving a great sunset show. We had the blood orange and cranberry sorbet for dessert which was a perfect ending to our meal. Our server Katie was very personable and attentive. This is by far RI BEST dining experience.

Mooring is an excellent restaurant. Food is always good and in the summer months, the outside dining is terrific. Tables spaces nicely. Service is always excellent.