Restaurants near Fifth Avenue

Amazing flavors, food and vibe. Can’t wait to go back!

Our first time here to celebrate my wife’s birthday. They are sticklers with your reservation time…no sooner, no later. The ambiance was like that of a movie set. They had a birthday card waiting on our table for my wife. The heaters were a nice balance to the outside air. Our waiter Solomon was charismatic, knowledgeable and offered great recommendations. Very impressed with the quality of food…bruschetta, short braised ribs and complimentary dessert for my wife’s birthday. We’ll definitely be coming back. Thank you for a delightful experience!!!

We visit Mastros City Hall very regularly - the food, the atmosphere, the drinks, everything is consistently amazing. Last night we went as a family (myself, my father, my husband, and our adult daughter). We sat at the bar with Cristian (bartender extraordinaire) and had the most wonderful dinner. He is absolutely the best guy there with the best heart and the best stories and drinks. We had a small issue with dinner - but Jeff the manager had it resolved efficiently and nicely. It is a pleasure for us to know these two fine gentlemen. They both went beyond any expectation for us amd we had the best night.

Wow! I was a little hesitant when I saw that they require a credit card for reservations, but the associate recommending B&B was so strong, I want ahead. We were not disappointed! Service was exceptional, food was the best. And the bourbon… tasty too! If you want great food, service and libations, this is your place!

From the moment we were greeted to the time we got our check this was a top-notch experience. We got the perfect table in the corner which allowed us to converse with family we hadn’t seen in two years. Our waiter Reese was very professional and attentive without being too attentive. It was very noisy at first but then it emptied out. Our food was superb. At our table of four, two of us had the salmon, one had the meatloaf, and one had the ribeye. For dessert we shared the salted caramel and chocolate chip cookies which were all very good. They certainly stick to their high standards and live up to their reputation. I highly recommend this restaurant.