Restaurants near Old Harbor Light

My husband and I were looking for a nice restaurant with good food that wasn’t overpriced and touristy while visiting Savannah and opted for trying B. Matthew’s Eatery. Best decision ever! The description on Google “Classic and new American fare in an updated vintage space with wood floors and exposed brick walls” was perfectly accurate and very pleasant and comfortable. The staff were all welcoming and the waiter was very attentive. Most importantly, the food was presented beautifully and tasted absolutely wonderful! We shared a Caesar Salad, B. Matt’s Famous Biscuits, Cheese Tortelloni appetizer and the Salmon entree. The tortelloni was amazing with a burnt tomato butter sauce that was so delicious! The salmon was cooked perfectly and moist with an amazing sauce. We were too full to order dessert. I can’t think of anything about the entire experience that I would change. If we’re ever in Savannah again, we will definitely return to B. Matthew’s Eatery. Highly recommend!

Chef Andrew is a fantastic chef and person. Go Pacci.

Very good food and nice choices, great service. It was Thanksgiving - reservations only, which we had. However, it seemed like they overbooked. We were finally seated 30 minutes after our reservation time. It took an hour to get our soup & salad and very long waits between courses. We were not out of there for over three hours! We’d try it again on a non-holiday night.

We had no idea what to expect, but what a great Thanksgiving Day buffet! I'm surprised they don't mention this on their website. Our server, Allie, was so friendly. All the staff did a great job. The food went above and beyond, we really enjoyed every bite! Worth the $$$$.

Very nice and quaint place. Food and service were amazing! Highly recommended.