Old San Juan Restaurants

Updated on 5/11/2024

Diners’ Choice Awards are based on where your fellow diners book, dine, and review. Only verified diners get to review restaurants on OpenTable, so our data doesn’t lie.

Azalea Old San Juan

Diners’ top pick

•

$$$$Price: Expensive

•

Contemporary Asian

•

4.9

(495)

Take the spice and punch of the Americas. Combine it with meticulously crafted Japanese dishes. Add the freshest local ingredients around. And what you get is more than just Nikkei cuisine. Its the meeting of traditions with an injection of flavor, plenty of zest and a dash of, así mismito está perfecto.

Find next available

---

Carli's Fine Bistro & Piano

$$$$Price: Expensive

•

Contemporary American

•

4.4

(520)

Carli's Fine Bistro & Piano located in the heart of historic Old San Juan Puerto Rico was born on December 27, 1998, as a place where locals and international patrons could gather to enjoy a unique live musical and fine dining experience in a relaxed atmosphere.
We have world-class live music nightly: Monday's and Thursdays we have jazz music at around 6:30 pm, and on Tue, Wed, Th, Friday & Saturday we have Jazz Piano from 8 PM, and on Saturday's, a Classic Rock Duo, from 6:30 PM.
Nested on the plaza level of the historic art deco Banco Popular building, Carli's warm and artistic vibe will charm you while you savor exotic assortments of gourmet tapas and exquisite international entrees, or sip on your favorite martini from our classic bar on our main room or under the stars with a view of the SJ Bay.
Carli’s excels in the art of fine dining and live jazz entertainment, without sacrificing the comfort of casual elegance and competitive pricing. Live music begins nightly.

Sofia’s Old San Juan

$$$$Price: Moderate

•

Italian

•

4.5

(97)

Located at #364 Fortaleza Street, Sofia’s Old San Juan is the only Italian Steakhouse. It Brings New Flavors and Flair to The Traditional Italian Cuisine, a Combination of International Flavors, Prime Beef Cuts and The Best Service in Town Will Place Sofia’s as the Hottest Restaurant in Old San Juan. Join Us and Discover the Flavors of Sofia’s Old San Juan.

CARNES STEAKHOUSE

Top-rated food

•

$$$$Price: Very Expensive

•

Steakhouse

•

4

(125)

Located on the fourth floor of the Hotel Puerto Valdés, in Puerta de Tierra, it has a view of the San Juan Bay and one of the most complete Argentine wine cellars locally. Its cuisine offers a wide variety of select cuts of meat, poultry and seafood that are roasted using the thousand-year-old concept of Kamado.
But what is Kamado? It is an ancient art of cooking meat that allows its flavors and textures to be unique and of an exquisite flavor for the palate. As our executive chef Paxx Caraballo describes us “cooking meat in Kamado is an art. Carnes Steakhouse offers a relaxed atmosphere for dinner. On its terrace, the visitor will be able to observe the beautiful bay of San Juan, and when there are cruise ships, the view is much more interesting.
To accompany the meats, the pairing is made with a delicious selection of Argentine wines in a cellar that includes an interesting variety.

Find next available

---

El Viejo Almacén en Viejo San Juan

$$$$Price: Expensive

•

Argentinean

•

4.3

(203)

Argentinean Cuisine in the heart of Old San Juan. Please come & visit.

El Asador

$$$$Price: Moderate

•

Steakhouse

•

4

(494)

El Asador The Grill-house Old San Juan, Puerto Rico, where you can find the best seafood, meat cuts and Puerto Rican cuisine, has a prime location in Old San Juan's entrance, and right in the heart of the Old City's nightlife. The stylish and exclusive décor of this Bar & Restaurant, accentuated by a magnificent interior patio, provides the perfect environment for a delightful, cozy and sophisticated experience. Whether you are looking for an early lunch, a romantic dinner, or even if you are looking to have a couple of drinks with friends, El Asador The Grill-house Old San Juan, Puerto Rico is your ultimate destination.
El Asador The Grill-house Old San Juan. Ideal for large groups, special, private or corporate events, weddings and rehearsal dinners.
For information, contact us via phone 787-382-0325 or via email at info@elasadorpr.com. You can also visit our website at www.elasadorpr.com