West Milford Restaurants

We were celebrating my husband’s birthday. The restaurant called me a couple of days before and asked for his name. Our table had printed special menu with a note saying happy birthday and his name on it. It was very special and he really enjoyed his birthday. Staff was amazing and food was unbelievable. We will definitely be back in the future.

Took my mom here on a Saturday night. We did the 5:30p seating. Decor and mood lighting was gorgeous! Owner made his rounds and greeted us. Our server, Julian, was attentive, frequently checked on us, and was well versed in the menu and specials. Smaller tables to accommodate the smaller Main Street venue, but they make it work where you don’t feel too crammed. Unfortunately a lot of noise as we were in a dining room with a larger party going on. Food was delicious- I ordered the homemade fettuccini and my mom the cherry braised short rib!! Recommend both!! Overall a truly lovely Italian spot at an easy location in town! Thank you, Bici!!

The food was excellent. My husband never had octopus before. He was impressed with it. Steak was cooked perfectly. The bacon macaroni and cheese was wonderful. Creamy, and full of bacon flavor. Hazelnut gelato for dessert was a perfect end to the delicious meal. They even put a candle in the gelato to celebrate my husbands birthday. Will return for special occasions.

Lovely Christmas luncheon with my staff. Beautifully decorated for the holidays with long-standing very attentive staff. Spinach pie is always a standout along with any fish. A wonderful leisurely lunch.

This was our first visit. Restaurant is beautiful decorated and furnished inside. Service was top notch and food was excellent. They also have an amazing wine list with something to match everyone’s budget. We felt extremely well taken care of! Highly recommend for a great elegant and proper experience.