Best Neighbourhood Gem Restaurants in Sheridan

Tonight was our first time at Anthony's Chophouse. Our server, David, was amazing, and made great suggestions on wine and food, perfectly timed our courses and was all around outstanding. The food was outstanding, everything we tried was spot on. This will be our go to place for special occasions.

Eli took great care of us. He took time to recommend tips on our order which turned out he made the right call. We both had steaks cooked to perfection. Bread pudding could serve a small family. Service, atmosphere and food were amazing. Will be back

per usual, had the best experience! i love the fried ravioli, so delicious! i could go on for daysss how much i LOVE the bread. it's the best italian bread i've ever had in the states (been to italia twice). and the bolognese is my favorite meal & ALWAYS comes out piping hot. and i was so happy to have cassie as our server, she is one of my absolute favorites at italian house! she knows the menu well, is always so kind & friendly, and i just love going back to places that remember me! overall the perfect experience yet again! italian house is my favorite restaurant in indiana.

We enjoyed a great meal with excellent service. The oysters were so fresh and delicious; sea bass was outstanding, best in our region! And my husband enjoyed the steak. Each entry was complimented with tasty, chef inspired and prepared accompaniments such as squash and polenta. Absolutely delicious. We will be back.

Coming back to Indianapolis after many years we made it a point to come to st. Elmo for a celebration with family and we were not disappointed. Our services Will was charming, funny and very knowledgeable about the menu and selection of drinks ( which wow is impressive itself) my husband, brother and sister n law had steak and mashed potatoes I had the South African lobster and my goodness cooked to perfection melted into our mouths .. definitely a treat and the dessert were yummy as well .