Best Italian Restaurants in McGregor

Price

€€
€€€
€€€€

Regions

Bonita SpringsFt. Myers

Areas

Cape CoralEsteroFort MyersFort Myers BeachMcGregorSan Carlos Park

Top Rated

CharmingDog-friendlyFancyGood for business mealsGood for groupsGood for special occasions

Dining Options

All dining options

Delivery only

Takeaway only

Seating options

BarCounterStandardHigh TopOutdoor

Accessibility

Gender-neutral toiletWheelchair access

11 restaurants available nearby

1. Mastello

4.7

Exceptional(572)

€€€€Price: Expensive

• Italian • Fort Myers

Booked 31 times today

Mastello in Fort Myers is a culinary gem that brings the heart of Italy to Southwest Florida. Renowned for its authentic Italian cuisine, Mastello offers an exceptional dining experience that locals and visitors alike rave about. As one review states, “The Italian fare is delicious, the steaks perfectly aged.” Diners are treated to expertly prepared dishes like the Risotto di Mare, brimming with succulent seafood, and the Cacio e Pepe, reminiscent of Roman delights. With a revamped interior, an extensive wine list, and a commitment to quality, Mastello ensures every meal is a celebration of Italian culinary traditions. Make a reservation today and indulge in some of the best Italian cuisine Fort Myers has to offer!

A photo of Terra Nostra Restaurant restaurant

2. Terra Nostra Restaurant

4.8

Exceptional(2165)

€€€€Price: Expensive

• Italian • Fort Myers Beach

Booked 39 times today

Terra Nostra Restaurant is a seafood lover's paradise in Fort Myers, where each dish is crafted with authenticity and flair. Diners rave about the Seafood Fra Diavolo, describing it as "excellent" and praising its rich flavors. The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident in their use of fresh ingredients, ensuring every bite is a delight. The seafood offerings are complemented by an exquisite wine selection, enhancing the dining experience. With a large patio and ambient atmosphere, Terra Nostra provides an ideal setting to savor their standout seafood dishes. It's no wonder patrons return year after year for this exceptional culinary experience.

A photo of La Fontanella Ristorante - Fort Myers restaurant

3. La Fontanella Ristorante - Fort Myers

4.8

Exceptional(284)

€€€€Price: Moderate

• Italian • McGregor

Booked 19 times today

We're glad that you're here. We pride ourselves in serving you authentic, from-scratch Italian dishes made only from the freshest, highest quality ingredients. We provide a vast selection of fine wines and hand crafted cocktails to further culminate your meal, and fresh, from-scratch desserts to conclude. Along with our warm, inviting atmosphere and friendly professional service, you can be assured that we at La Fontanella strive to exceed your expectations each time that you join us for a meal. It is always our pleasure to serve you. We look forward to meeting you.

4. Trattoria Ciao

4.7

Exceptional(180)

€€€€Price: Expensive

• Italian • Cape Coral

Booked 9 times today

Trattoria Ciao in Cape Coral is a hidden gem for Seafood enthusiasts, offering an authentic and delightful dining experience. Known for its exquisite Seafood dishes, the restaurant's menu features fresh and high-quality ingredients that capture the essence of Italian culinary traditions. One reviewer raves about the "shrimp dish in a butter artichoke caper lemon sauce," highlighting its perfect balance of flavors. The cozy and intimate ambiance, coupled with attentive service, makes every visit memorable. With live music enhancing the dining experience, Trattoria Ciao promises a taste of Italy in every bite, making it a must-visit for Seafood lovers.

5. il Pomodoro

4.6

Exceptional(371)

€€€€Price: Moderate

• Italian • Fort Myers

Booked 10 times today

Il Pomodoro in Fort Myers offers an exceptional Sicilian dining experience that delights both locals and visitors. Known for its authentic Sicilian dishes and use of fresh local ingredients, this restaurant has garnered numerous accolades, including the Trip Advisor's Traveler's Choice Award. Diners rave about the "fantastic experience" and "fresh and flavorful" cuisine, with dishes like the Salmon Martina and Rigatoni Bolognese frequently highlighted as favorites. The atmosphere, reminiscent of a vintage New York dinner club, is enhanced by live music and a welcoming, attentive staff. Il Pomodoro is truly a "secret gem" of Southwest Florida, promising an unforgettable culinary journey.

A photo of Da Michele Osteria e Pizzeria restaurant

6. Da Michele Osteria e Pizzeria

3.7

Very Good(6)

€€€€Price: Moderate

• Italian • Villas

At our corner, we like to think of Da Michele Osteria e Pizzeria as our cozy spot, where the essence of authentic food, fresh ingredients, and a welcoming ambience is what we embody. Wake up, get out of the bed and straightaway head into da Michele and you will feel home.

7. 41 Bistro

4.7

Exceptional(383)

€€€€Price: Moderate

• Italian • San Carlos Park

Booked 20 times today

41 Bistro in San Carlos Park, Fort Myers, is a seafood lover's paradise, renowned for its exceptional and authentic seafood dishes. Guests rave about the “delicious seafood pasta” and “excellently cooked salmon,” underscoring the restaurant's commitment to quality. Each dish is crafted with the freshest ingredients, bringing the true essence of Italian cuisine to life. The seafood risotto and clams linguine with white sauce are standouts, earning glowing reviews for their flavor and presentation. The attentive and friendly staff enhance the dining experience, making 41 Bistro a must-visit destination for those seeking a superb seafood meal.

A photo of Rae's Real Italian restaurant

8. Rae's Real Italian

4.6

Exceptional(304)

€€€€Price: Expensive

• Italian • Fort Myers

Booked 14 times today

Rae's Real Italian, nestled in the heart of Fort Myers Beach, offers a delightful fusion of American charm and Italian culinary excellence. Known for its "authentic and fresh" flavors, this beachfront gem captivates diners with its breathtaking views and "phenomenal" service. While the name may suggest Italian, Rae's expertly crafts American cuisine with a flair, making it a must-visit for those seeking quality and authenticity. Guests rave about the "superb" dining experience, emphasizing the "great food" and "wonderful service" that make every meal memorable. Whether savoring the sunset or indulging in a special occasion, Rae's promises an unforgettable American dining adventure.

9. Next Door

4.9

Exceptional(189)

€€€€Price: Expensive

• Italian • Cape Coral

Booked 7 times today

Nestled in the heart of Cape Coral, Next Door shines as a beacon of exceptional Fusion/Eclectic cuisine. This charming restaurant expertly marries authentic traditional recipes with a modern twist, creating a unique dining experience that is both innovative and comforting. Guests rave about the "refreshing spin on scratch pasta," with fresh dishes crafted daily in their open kitchen, showcasing the artistry of their chefs. From the exquisite wagyu carpaccio to the succulent scallops, every dish is a testament to their commitment to quality and creativity. With a thoughtfully curated wine list and a cozy atmosphere, Next Door is a must-visit for food enthusiasts seeking an unforgettable culinary adventure.

10. Pezzo Pizza + Bar

4.7

Exceptional(84)

€€€€Price: Moderate

• Italian • Estero

Booked 13 times today

Pezzo Pizza + Bar in Estero is a delightful gem offering exceptional Contemporary Italian cuisine that artfully blends traditional flavors with modern flair. With Head Chef Crecenzo DePasquale's dedication to authenticity and quality, diners are treated to a menu that bursts with "outstanding flavor" and creativity. From the hand-stuffed Lobster Raviolis to the perfectly crafted gourmet pizzas, every dish is a testament to the chef’s roots in Napoli. Guests rave about the "amazing sauce" on the eggplant parm and the "spicy baby" pizza, making it "our new favorite pizza joint." Pezzo's inviting atmosphere and attentive service make every visit a memorable experience.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

S
Sabrina
East Tennessee •5 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Lovely restaurant with delicious offerings. Four of us dined, Risotto with seafood was excellent as well as the other 3 dinners, Chicken Marsala, Bolegnase, and Veal Piccata. The Risotto had clams, lobster, shrimp and scallops in it. They were well presented, and really hot. The service was excellent. Would definitely go back.
More info
MastelloPrice: Expensive• Steakhouse• Fort Myers
•
4.7
MF
MichaelFVIP
Nashville •37 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Food and service were excellent… you’re not going for the ambience. I would definitely recommend Trattoria Ciao to anyone who’s looking for a great dining experience
More info
Trattoria CiaoPrice: Expensive• Italian• Cape Coral
•
4.7
OT
OpenTable DinerVIP
Columbus •1 review
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
This is a hidden gem with fantastic food and fantastic service. My daughter and I enjoyed our experience immensely.
More info
La Fontanella Ristorante - Fort MyersPrice: Moderate• Italian• McGregor
•
4.8
T
TimVIP
Toronto / Ontario •11 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
The food and service was excellent! Amanda was very friendly,helpfull and attentive! The fresh bread with olive butter, fried calamari, chicken parmigiana and shrimp ravioli pasta were top notch! Looking forward to our next visit. Well done!
More info
Terra Nostra RestaurantPrice: Expensive• Italian• Fort Myers Beach
•
4.8
J
Jim
Detroit / Eastern Michigan •5 reviews
5.0
Dined on 22 Feb 2025
Had the Salmon Martina. It was excellent with goat cheese, roasted peppers, and generous portion of artichoke hearts. Wife had Chicken Scaloppini and she said the chicken was very moist and a lot of artichokes. Garlic rolls were amazing. Definitely recommend.
More info
il PomodoroPrice: Moderate• Italian• Fort Myers
•
4.6

Explore OpenTable

Area
Cuisine nearby
Italian cuisine

McGregor

Italian

Cape Coral
Naples
Sanibel
Marco Island
Vineyards
Pelican Bay
Lely Resort
Villas
San Carlos Park
East Naples
Naples
Bonita Springs
South Naples
Iona
North Naples
McGregor
Golden Gate
Fort Myers Beach
Estero
Fort Myers