Best Seafood Restaurants in Fisher Island

Easily one of the top 10 restaurants in Miami. Service, ambience, and food are consistently excellent. Every single person on the staff with whom we interacted was professional and welcoming, and we felt appreciated. Our captain, Brigi (sp?) was attentive and informative and helped us to understand all the spectacular seafood options. I am also partial to the Holland peppers and they did not disappoint. This was the second time we've done Valentine's Day at Milos and it is hard to beat.

We had an amazing time during our first visit to the Rusty Pelican. Valentina was the highlight of our night and made sure to answer every single one of our questions and gave amazing direction to which dishes were best. We went for the Sea bass with smoked plantain mash and the Squid Ink bucatini. Those dishes were breathtaking, the bucatini had a sizable portion of both lobster and shrimp with a delicious red sauce on top of perfectly cooked pasta. The Sea Bass was cooked to perfection and was like butter with every bite complimenting the bold, fresh, sweet, savory flavor of the plantain mash made me forget to talk during dinner. Desert was tempting with the bread pudding but we didn’t have time. We look forward to experiencing this restaurant again soon!

Food is always exceptional at Prime 112. Service is typically very good. Last night I enjoyed service from Mr. Kyle King that ranks as some of the best ever. Kyle is a consummate professional on another level. We will return soon just to dine with Kyle.

Fantastic experience!!! The food, service, PRESENTATION...all of it was stellar! One of the best meals we've ever had.

We had such a wonderful experience at catch, specially due to Luis (our waiter). He always made us feel at home and treated us warmly and extremely politely. Thanks Luis!