Best American Restaurants in Edgartown
Price
- €25 and under
- €26 to €42
- €42 and over
Regions
Areas
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating options
Accessibility
4 restaurants available nearby
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- JJaredGreater Boston •2 reviews5.0Dined 2 days agoAnother great experience at Sail Loft for Valentine’s Day. Really nice, lovely atmosphere (not too stuffy and Valentine’s Day serious) and our meals were excellent. Started with drinks. The girlfriend had a spicy coconut margarita with a tajin rim, was delicious. For apps we had calamari and lobster rangoon, both were great. Main meal, we split a large piece of sautéed cod over asparagus and cauliflower mashed. So tender and well seasoned. Capped the night by splitting a slice of chocolate cookie crusted cheesecake served on top of a luxardo cherry puree. I can’t put into words how incredible it was. We love this place, it never disappoints. They put so much care and culinary talent into everything they serve. If you’re wondering whether to go to Sail Loft, stop wondering and just go. You won’t be disappointed.More infoSail Loft - DartmouthPrice: Expensive• American• Dartmouth•4.8
- SSandraGreater Boston •9 reviews5.0Dined 5 days agoWe thoroughly enjoyed evening out. We were lucky enough to book our reservation for the Tuesday candlelight night experience. The ambience was really quite relaxing and beautiful. The illumination of all the candles against the windows overlooking the ocean was just divine. There were many wonderful choices for entrees on the menu, however, my husband and I each had the evening's dinner specials which were excellent. I had the pasta dinner special (linguine with lobster, shrimp and scallops in a light ginger cream sauce) and my husband had the short rib dinner with mashed potatoes and haricot verts (french green beans). The server was pleasant, friendly and informative. We will definitely return again.More infoThe Coast Guard HousePrice: Moderate• Seafood• Narragansett•4.7
- MMaureenGreater Boston •8 reviews5.0Dined on 8 Feb 2025One of our favorite island restaurants. Always guaranteed to get a great meal. The food always tastes delicious. Perfectly seasoned with great flavors. Never bland. Service always great from the hostess to the servers to the bussers.More infoBettini RestaurantPrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Edgartown•4.9
- TTerryGreater Boston •6 reviews5.0Dined on 2 Sept 2024The food was very tasty and the flavors were “sophisticated “ according to our knowledgeable friends. The menu choices were very appealing, and the four of us thoroughly enjoyed our meals. The views from the upper floor cannot be beat.More infoGarde EastPrice: Expensive• Seafood• Martha's Vineyard•4.4
- BCBillCGreater Boston •6 reviews4.0Dined on 14 Jun 2024Great quiet place on site to ha e nice dinner. Small menu but excellent food. Highly recommend smash burger.More infoBehind the ViewPrice: Moderate• Pub• Edgartown•4.5
Discover best American restaurants in Edgartown
Discover the essence of American dining in Edgartown, Cape Cod and the Islands, Greater Boston, where a variety of restaurants capture the spirit of this rich culinary tradition. Each dining spot offers a unique blend of local flavors and classic American dishes, showcasing the area's commitment to freshness and quality. From succulent seafood sourced directly from the surrounding waters to expertly grilled meats and innovative comfort food, the options are both diverse and satisfying. The dining scene in Edgartown is characterized by its elegant yet casual atmosphere, making it an ideal location for both romantic dinners and family gatherings. Visitors can expect exceptional service and a welcoming environment that complements the flavorful offerings. These restaurants not only cater to the taste buds but also to the soul of every diner, promising an unforgettable American dining experience in the heart of Cape Cod. Whether you're a local or a tourist, these culinary establishments are sure to enhance your visit with their distinct charm and high-quality cuisine.