Customers can dine in the upscale elegant indoors furnished with wicker seats and grommet curtains or relax in the outdoor patio at Butterfly Cafe.
Important note: To guarantee outdoor dining with us please select \"Outdoor\" Seating at booking. Standard seating is indoors. If Outdoor Seating is not an option when you book, all outdoor tables are reserved at the time you selected.","diningStyle":"Fine Dining","publicTransit":"","executiveChef":null,"entertainment":null,"cateringDetails":null,"website":"http://www.tranquilitybay.com/dining/butterflycafe","hoursOfOperation":"Dinner\n Daily 6:00 pm–9:00 pm","parkingDetails":null,"parkingInfo":"Hotel Parking","dressCode":"Casual Dress","crossStreet":null,"additionalDetails":["Gluten-free Options"],"paymentOptions":["AMEX","Discover","Mastercard","Visa"],"type":"GuestCenter","stateId":1,"maxAdvanceDays":365,"rooms":null,"editorialLists":{"correlationId":"def10bb6-e6aa-4ca8-aa75-73bd2a24ed85","lists":[],"__typename":"EditorialLists"},"mostRecentReview":{"reviews":[{"text":"We had a great table outside. The weather was perfect, the wine was cold, the food was delicious, and the service was outstanding! A perfect night in paradise.","__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"}],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResults"},"photos":{"galleryV3":{"photos":[{"title":"","pid":55454389,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/55454389-3","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"food","width":5399,"height":3599,"timestamp":"2023-09-23T21:01:46Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"","pid":49795784,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/49795784-2","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"exterior","width":2000,"height":1333,"timestamp":"2022-10-08T19:26:41Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"Filet Mignon","pid":55454219,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/55454219-2","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"food","width":3648,"height":5472,"timestamp":"2023-09-23T20:54:56Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"","pid":55454233,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/55454233-2","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"food","width":2896,"height":4345,"timestamp":"2023-09-23T20:55:32Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"Crab Cakes","pid":55454242,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/55454242-2","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"food","width":3648,"height":5472,"timestamp":"2023-09-23T20:55:49Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"Crab Cakes","pid":55454252,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/55454252-2","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"food","width":5325,"height":3550,"timestamp":"2023-09-23T20:56:09Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"","pid":55454238,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/55454238-2","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"food","width":5399,"height":3599,"timestamp":"2023-09-23T20:55:42Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"","pid":55454285,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/55454285-2","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"food","width":5193,"height":3380,"timestamp":"2023-09-23T20:57:05Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"Key Lime Pie","pid":49795830,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/49795830-2","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"food","width":6000,"height":4000,"timestamp":"2022-10-08T19:35:30Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"Scallop Risotto","pid":55454179,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/55454179-2","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"food","width":3648,"height":5472,"timestamp":"2023-09-23T20:53:46Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"Butterfly Pork Chop","pid":55454270,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/55454270-2","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"food","width":5161,"height":3441,"timestamp":"2023-09-23T20:56:37Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"Tuna Napoleon","pid":49376584,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/49376584-2","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"food","width":1536,"height":2049,"timestamp":"2022-09-02T00:49:53Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"","pid":49795803,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/49795803-3","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"food","width":6000,"height":4000,"timestamp":"2022-10-08T19:31:16Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"Butterfly Martini","pid":49795821,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/49795821-2","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"drink","width":2000,"height":1333,"timestamp":"2022-10-08T19:34:21Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":null,"pid":73120355,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/73120355-1","creator":null,"source":"Diner","category":"interior","width":3024,"height":4032,"timestamp":"2025-02-04T22:18:05Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"}],"__typename":"GalleryPhotosV3","totalCount":136,"categories":[{"name":"food","count":106,"__typename":"PhotoCategories"},{"name":"drink","count":14,"__typename":"PhotoCategories"},{"name":"exterior","count":7,"__typename":"PhotoCategories"},{"name":"other","count":5,"__typename":"PhotoCategories"},{"name":"interior","count":4,"__typename":"PhotoCategories"}],"showMosaic":false},"profile":{"xsmall":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/xsmall/3/55454389.jpg","width":105,"height":105,"__typename":"Thumbnail"},"large":{"url":"https://images.otstatic.com/prod1/55454389/3/large.jpg","width":640,"height":640,"__typename":"Thumbnail"},"__typename":"RestaurantProfile"},"__typename":"RestaurantPhotos"},"address":{"line1":"2600 Overseas Hwy","line2":"","state":"FL","city":"Marathon","postCode":"33050-2243","country":"United States","__typename":"Address"},"contactInformation":{"formattedPhoneNumber":"(305) 289-7177","__typename":"RestaurantContactInformation"},"metro":{"metroId":85,"statistics":{"restaurantCount":414,"__typename":"MetroStatistics"},"urls":{"premiumLandingLink":{"link":"https://www.opentable.ie/premium?m=85","__typename":"PageLink"},"__typename":"MetroUrls"},"displayName":"Key West","__typename":"Metro"},"timeZone":{"offsetInMinutes":-240,"__typename":"RestaurantTimeZone"},"coordinates":{"latitude":24.7107274,"longitude":-81.1008589,"mapUrl":"https://maps.googleapis.com/maps/api/staticmap?key=AIzaSyBHDlZeuOrKam8hwQCouMlwI-hNAqacPtM&size=288x144&language=en-IE&markers=color%3A0x6AADCC%7C24.7107274%2C-81.1008589&signature=mByfBw4XnqI2fzXFCiG2Z72QzQs=","__typename":"GeographicCoordinates"},"priceBand":{"currencySymbol":"$","priceBandId":3,"name":"$31 to $50","__typename":"PriceBand"},"statistics":{"recentReservationCount":7,"reviews":{"allTimeTextReviewCount":478,"showReviews":true,"totalNumberOfReviews":201,"verifiedReviews":true,"ratingBasedOn":"RecentReviews","awards":[{"location":"Key West / Florida Keys","name":"Best Ambience","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"},{"location":"Key West / Florida Keys","name":"American","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"},{"location":"Florida Keys - Monroe County","name":"Best Ambience","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"},{"location":"Florida Keys - Monroe County","name":"American","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"}],"ratings":{"count":201,"overall":{"rating":4.6,"__typename":"ReviewStatisticsRating"},"ambience":{"rating":4.8,"count":201,"__typename":"ReviewStatisticsRating"},"food":{"rating":4.6,"count":201,"__typename":"ReviewStatisticsRating"},"service":{"rating":4.5,"count":201,"__typename":"ReviewStatisticsRating"},"value":{"rating":4.1,"count":201,"__typename":"ReviewStatisticsRating"},"noise":{"rating":2,"count":201,"__typename":"ReviewStatisticsRating"},"overallRatingsDistribution":{"one":1,"two":3,"three":20,"four":20,"five":157,"__typename":"OverallRatingsDistribution"},"__typename":"ReviewStatisticsRatings"},"changeOfConceptType":"","changeOfConceptDateTimeUtc":null,"categories":[{"category":{"name":"Charming","key":"Charming","__typename":"ReviewCategory"},"__typename":"ReviewCategoryWithCount"},{"category":{"name":"Good for special occasions","key":"SpecialOccasions","__typename":"ReviewCategory"},"__typename":"ReviewCategoryWithCount"},{"category":{"name":"Great for outdoor dining","key":"OutdoorDining","__typename":"ReviewCategory"},"__typename":"ReviewCategoryWithCount"}],"__typename":"ReviewStatistics"},"__typename":"RestaurantStatistics"},"primaryCuisine":{"cuisineId":"8afc7adc-de3b-439d-91f2-ce568c1a653b","name":"American","__typename":"Cuisine"},"experiences":[{"experienceId":465065,"name":"Mother's Day at Butterfly Cafe 2025","description":"Celebrate Mother's Day at Butterfly Cafe with that special woman in your life. Enjoy options from our starters list, as well as our delicious entrees.","typeEnum":"PRIX_FIXE","bookable":true,"type":"Special menu","featuredPhoto":{"photo":{"photoBySize":{"small":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/small/2/72455146.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideMedium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-medium/2/72455146.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"__typename":"PhotoSizes"},"__typename":"PhotoMetadata"},"__typename":"ExperiencePhoto"},"nonFeaturedPhotos":[{"photo":{"photoBySize":{"small":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/small/1/76535499.png","__typename":"Photo"},"wideMedium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-medium/1/76535499.png","__typename":"Photo"},"__typename":"PhotoSizes"},"__typename":"PhotoMetadata"},"__typename":"ExperiencePhoto"}],"photos":[{"photo":{"photoBySize":{"xlarge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/xlarge/2/72455146.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"huge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/huge/2/72455146.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"small":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/small/2/72455146.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideMedium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-medium/2/72455146.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideLarge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-large/2/72455146.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideHuge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-huge/2/72455146.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"__typename":"PhotoSizes"},"__typename":"PhotoMetadata"},"__typename":"ExperiencePhoto"},{"photo":{"photoBySize":{"xlarge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/xlarge/1/76535499.png","__typename":"Photo"},"huge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/huge/1/76535499.png","__typename":"Photo"},"small":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/small/1/76535499.png","__typename":"Photo"},"wideMedium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-medium/1/76535499.png","__typename":"Photo"},"wideLarge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-large/1/76535499.png","__typename":"Photo"},"wideHuge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-huge/1/76535499.png","__typename":"Photo"},"__typename":"PhotoSizes"},"__typename":"PhotoMetadata"},"__typename":"ExperiencePhoto"}],"priceInfo":null,"location":null,"pricePerCover":null,"schedule":{"startDate":"2025-05-11","endDate":"2025-05-11","weekSchedule":[],"blocked":[],"ticketedSchedules":[],"__typename":"ExperienceSchedule"},"version":1,"__typename":"Experience"}],"cuisines":[{"name":"American","__typename":"Cuisine"},{"name":"Seafood","__typename":"Cuisine"}],"macro":{"macroId":190,"__typename":"Macro"},"features":{"permanentlyClosed":false,"waitlistV2Only":false,"waitlistV2Enabled":true,"networkNonBookable":null,"prioritySeatingEnabled":null,"bar":false,"counter":false,"highTop":false,"outdoor":true,"optsOutOfLoyaltyRedemptions":null,"giftsURLs":null,"giftsEnabled":null,"suppressDinerGeneratedContent":null,"reservationMaxPartySize":12,"inPremiumMarketplace":false,"paymentProcessor":null,"visaDiningProgram":null,"chaseDiningProgram":null,"dinerAiEnabled":true,"subtype":null,"visaEventsProgram":null,"__typename":"RestaurantFeatures"},"whyPremiumMarketplace":null,"neighborhood":{"neighborhoodId":9011,"name":"Marathon","coordinates":{"latitude":24.712572,"longitude":-81.08543,"__typename":"GeographicCoordinates"},"__typename":"Neighborhood"},"hasTakeout":true,"hasDeliveryPartners":false,"hasDeliveryDirect":false,"hasWhiteLabelDelivery":false,"orderOnlineLink":null,"whiteLabelDelivery":null,"deliveryPartners":[],"facebookUrl":null,"localization":{"address":"en-US","__typename":"RestaurantLocalization"},"country":{"countryId":"US","__typename":"Country"},"popularDishes":{"correlationId":"6ac89f11-0015-4b17-a17d-4febe244820c","dishes":[{"dishId":"293512-ecb79c0b8d099ea3b2b97eb943d5b8d1","name":"Pork Rib Chop","description":"Baked and Roasted Pan Jus Gratin Potatoes Vegetable of the Day","reviewCount":3,"reviews":[{"reviewId":"OT-293512-14307-150091978935","text":"Ordered aged pork chop medium. 1 of 2 was over cooked.","submittedDateTime":"2024-04-18T16:10:23Z","rating":{"overall":4,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"EddieG","isVip":null,"profileColor":"PLUM","initials":"EG","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":13,"endIndex":22,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-14151-120034570222","text":"We hadn’t been there for a couple years, however is was definitely as good as we remembered. Beautiful setting, outstanding service and cold drinks, and delicious meals. I had the pork chop and it was cooked perfectly. We will be back for sure.","submittedDateTime":"2024-04-10T16:07:13Z","rating":{"overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"Sparky1976","isVip":true,"profileColor":"PUMPKIN","initials":"S","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":180,"endIndex":189,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-9376-100003396300","text":"Excellent meal. The risotto and the pork chop were one of the best we ever had. Waitress was exceptional we went there twice and would highly recommend it","submittedDateTime":"2023-09-21T14:20:54Z","rating":{"overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":null,"isVip":null,"profileColor":"MUSTARD","initials":"OT","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":36,"endIndex":45,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"}],"photos":[{"photoMetaData":{"title":null,"photoBySize":{"small":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/small/1/74396068.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"medium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/medium/1/74396068.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideMedium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-medium/1/74396068.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideLarge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-large/1/74396068.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"__typename":"PhotoSizes"},"__typename":"PhotoMetadata"},"__typename":"DishPhoto"}],"__typename":"Dish"},{"dishId":"293512-d3384afadea7ec82e57359f2358f8b27","name":"Filet Mignon","description":"8 oz Filet Mignon Onion Marmalade Wine Demi Glace Yukon Gold Mashed Potatoes Vegetable of the Day","reviewCount":7,"reviews":[{"reviewId":"OT-293512-14975-120087130992","text":"Our waitress, Nara, was absolutely fantastic. She was attentive and very sweet. And per some of her recommendations, our meal was also fantastic. Our filet mignon’s were cooked perfectly and delicious. Thanks to the chefs as well. Great overall experience.","submittedDateTime":"2024-05-07T16:44:52Z","rating":{"overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"DDarling","isVip":null,"profileColor":"MUSTARD","initials":"DD","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":150,"endIndex":162,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-12001-170041790987","text":"We had a very enjoyable meal at Butterfly Cafe. Our only disappointment was they changed the menu and altered the recipe for what my husband usually orders. My steak was cooked perfectly and I loved the sides. The Crustless chocolate pie was good too! Plan to spend some money but you will have no complaints.","submittedDateTime":"2024-01-24T21:38:45Z","rating":{"overall":4,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"Motherdaughterbreakfast","isVip":null,"profileColor":"PLUM","initials":"M","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":162,"endIndex":167,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-10002-190021217019","text":"I usually don't feel compelled to write reviews - but the Butterfly Cafe exceeded my expectations in many ways! Food was well portioned and seasoned/cooked to perfection. Staff was so friendly and helpful in suggesting favorite items. We loved the tuna appetizer, caesar salad (loved the vinegar kick), ribeye and filet. Fantastic meal all around. Do not miss the date cake toffee sauce dessert - it's amazing. Absolutely delicious all around - a hidden gem that we will keep on the top of our list of favorites.","submittedDateTime":"2023-11-23T17:34:01Z","rating":{"overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"Lifesaver615","isVip":null,"profileColor":"PLUM","initials":"L","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":{"xsmall":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/xsmall/1/73153447.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"__typename":"PhotoSizes"},"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":314,"endIndex":319,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-9983-150107220135","text":"Best key lime pie in the Keys! Good service. Loved the steak","submittedDateTime":"2023-10-29T17:59:52Z","rating":{"overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":null,"isVip":null,"profileColor":"PLUM","initials":"OT","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":55,"endIndex":60,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-9607-130007909453","text":"Lovely Restaurant. After many years butterfly still delivers a nice experience. On Thursday 10/5/23 we enjoyed a corner table, inside. The hostess was just wonderful. Turned out she was the server assistant and ended up bussing and resetting tables too! Our server, Nara was great. Appetizers of shrimp cocktail and warm goat cheese were ok. Caesar salad was blah. Bone-in rib steak and filet were good. Our entrees were served warm, I like hot food to be served hot and cold food to be served cold. Nara suggested a dessert that I would come back to butterfly for, a warm spice cake with a decadent caramel sauce(I suggest they serve it with vanilla ice cream). Overall a nice dinner at a lovely property.","submittedDateTime":"2023-10-06T12:26:02Z","rating":{"overall":4,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"MichaelL","isVip":null,"profileColor":"ICECREAM","initials":"ML","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":387,"endIndex":392,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"}],"photos":[{"photoMetaData":{"title":"Filet Mignon","photoBySize":{"small":{"url":"https://images.otstatic.com/prod1/55454219/2/small.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"medium":{"url":"https://images.otstatic.com/prod1/55454219/2/medium.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideMedium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-medium/2/55454219.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideLarge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-large/2/55454219.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"__typename":"PhotoSizes"},"__typename":"PhotoMetadata"},"__typename":"DishPhoto"}],"__typename":"Dish"},{"dishId":"293512-058534f2363f641ea118fae209e8cb54","name":"Mahi Mahi","description":"Grilled Mahi Mahi Pineapple Chutney Sundried Tomato Truffle Risotto Vegetable of the Day","reviewCount":4,"reviews":[{"reviewId":"OT-293512-14072-120145513572","text":"We enjoyed a delicious meal at the Butterfly Cafe. This was the 1st night of our vacation. The drinks, the crab cake appetizer, and the MahiMahi were outstanding. Our server - Jasmine was top notch. Quick with her service and provided excellent recomendations.","submittedDateTime":"2024-04-16T18:16:11Z","rating":{"overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"KevinL","isVip":null,"profileColor":"MUSTARD","initials":"KL","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":138,"endIndex":146,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-13659-130066267873","text":"One of the best ambiences experienced in a restaurant. Great views of the resort grounds including partial water view. The indoor restaurant high ceiling & sophisticated beams stole the view! Our order consisted of conch soup - spicy at same time the flavor was in abundance & read through past the heat. Also had the yellow tail and mahi mahi - both very good. Especially the key lime buttery sauce with the Mahi Mahi - more please! Excellent wine selection. Many red wine blends & lighter hints fruitier whites & perfect pairings for the Keys. Think white linens, comfy seating, low noise, good lighting, and casual to dressy casual attire. Saw casual shirts with nicer shorts and sandals up to button down shirts and skirts and dresses but no baseball hats.","submittedDateTime":"2024-03-17T02:04:11Z","rating":{"overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":null,"isVip":true,"profileColor":"ICECREAM","initials":"OT","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":409,"endIndex":418,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"},{"startIndex":334,"endIndex":343,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-7409-130077505223","text":"Simple meal locally sourced, very small portion Mahi did not warrant extremely high price \nService was excellent","submittedDateTime":"2023-06-16T14:05:01Z","rating":{"overall":3,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"Cali","isVip":null,"profileColor":"PLUM","initials":"C","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":48,"endIndex":52,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-5667-130008700913","text":"Beautiful restaurant with great ambiance and we sat outside. Before we ordered dinner we quickly escaped down to the Tiki hut and beach which were cool and energetic. Nice place to hang for evening. When we returned we ordered drinks and appetizers which included the crab cakes which were tasty and full of crab. Drinks were good and well proportioned. Bread was wonderful so don’t miss that. They had two types including Asiago cheese and Rosemary. Daughter ate too much of the Rosemary which came warm and with whipped butter that she lost her appetite. It was good and a must have! The waitress was wonderful and caring and very knowledgeable of the menu. Ordered the Mahi and wife the PorkChops and both were good but had better at other place. Try not to sit outside toward dusk as it gets dark and you can’t see your meals as they won’t turn the lighting up to see. The key lime was award winning and came just that way! Also had the brownie and ice cream and there was nothing left. Very good place but might be able to do better with entrees..","submittedDateTime":"2023-04-14T18:44:52Z","rating":{"overall":4,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"RichU","isVip":true,"profileColor":"ICECREAM","initials":"RU","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":676,"endIndex":680,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"}],"photos":[],"__typename":"Dish"}],"__typename":"PopularDishes"},"__typename":"Restaurant","diningAreas":[{"name":"Other","diningAreaId":1,"description":"Other","tag":"Other","localeMatch":true,"active":true,"preProcessedAreaId":null,"__typename":"DiningAreaMetaData"},{"name":"2 top solution","diningAreaId":36579,"description":"When we need two tops we split 72","tag":"Dining Room","localeMatch":true,"active":true,"preProcessedAreaId":null,"__typename":"DiningAreaMetaData"}],"privateDining":{"hasPrivateDining":false,"hasEnhancedPrivateDining":false,"description":null,"formattedPhone":null,"contact":"","largestCapacity":0,"__typename":"PrivateDining"},"seoTranslations":{"metaTitle":"%(restaurantName)s Restaurant - %(locationName)s | Book on OpenTable","__typename":"SeoTranslations"},"restaurantReviewSummary":{"summary":"Butterfly Café offers a \"beautiful setting\" and \"excellent service,\" with standout dishes like \"scallops and risotto\" and \"stuffed hogfish.\" Guests appreciate the \"relaxing atmosphere\" and \"delicious desserts\" like the \"TDF date cake.\" While some find it \"pricey,\" the overall \"dining experience\" is praised, making it \"worth every penny.\"","__typename":"RestaurantReviewSummaryGenerativeContent"},"awards":[]},"menus":{"menuData":[{"title":"Butterfly Cafe Dinner Menu","description":"","currency":{"code":"USD","__typename":"MenuCurrency"},"sections":[{"title":"Appetizers","description":"","items":[{"title":"Spinach Artichoke Dip**","description":"Served Hot, Fresh Diced Tomato, Pita Bread","price":"16.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Shrimp Cocktail","description":"Pink Shrimp, Traditional Cocktail Sauce","price":"21.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Warm Goat Cheese","description":"Marcona Almond Crust, Amarena Cherries","price":"22.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Tuna Napoleon* **","description":"Ahi Tuna, Toasted Sesame Seeds, Avocado, Pickled Ginger, Wontons, Ginger Sesame Dressing","price":"23.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Lump Crab Cakes","description":"Jicama Slaw, Chipotle Aioli","price":"25.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Soup","description":"","items":[{"title":"Soup of the Day","description":"","price":"12.00","variationGroups":[{"items":[{"title":"Cup","price":"12.00","__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Bowl","price":"17.00","__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuVariationGroup"}],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Salads","description":"Add Ons: Catch of the Day $14 | Shrimp (6) - $12 | Chicken $8 | Crab Cake (1) - $11 | Scallops (2) - $10","items":[{"title":"Caesar Salad**","description":"Romaine, Shaved Parmesan, Brioche Croutons, Parmesan Crisp, House Caesar Dressing","price":"17.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Roasted Beet Salad**","description":"Tender Beets, Bitter Greens, Fried Onions, Goat Cheese, Sweet Onion Vinaigrette","price":"18.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Caprese Salad","description":"Fresh Florida Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella, Balsamic, Virgin Olive Oil, Fresh Basil, Cracked Pepper","price":"18.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Butterfly Salad**","description":"Mixed Greens, Caramelized Onions, Carrots, Corn, Feta Cheese, Wonton Strips, Mango Balsamic Vinaigrette","price":"19.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Land","description":"Add Ons: Grilled Onions | $4, Cilantro Lime Butter | $4, Scallops (2) | $10, Blue Cheese Crumbles | $4, Lump Crab Meat | $10, Grilled Shrimp (6) | $12","items":[{"title":"Pork Rib Chop","description":"Baked and Roasted, Pan Jus, Gratin Potatoes, Vegetable of the Day","price":"48.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Tropical Jerk Chicken","description":"Marinated Bone-In Breast, Pineapple Chutney, Coconut Rice, Vegetable of the Day","price":"46.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Filet Mignon*","description":"8 oz Filet Mignon, Onion Marmalade, Wine Demi Glace, Yukon Gold Mashed Potatoes, Vegetable of the Day","price":"59.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Cowboy* **","description":"22 oz Bone-In Angus Ribeye, Wine Demi Glace, Truffle Bistro Fries, Vegetable of the Day","price":"69.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Sea","description":"","items":[{"title":"Mahi Mahi","description":"Grilled Mahi Mahi, Pineapple Chutney, Sundried Tomato Truffle Risotto, Vegetable of the Day","price":"46.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Yellowtail Francaise","description":"Lightly Battered Filets Sautéed, Lemon and Caper Butter Sauce, Yukon Gold Mashed Potatoes, Vegetable of the Day","price":"48.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Crab Stuffed Hogfish","description":"Hogfish Filled With Crab Stuffing Broiled, Key Lime Hollandaise Sauce, Yukon Gold Mashed Potatoes, Vegetable of the Day","price":"52.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Butterfly Risotto*","description":"Choice of Scallop or Shrimp; Pesto Parmesan Risotto, Roasted Red Pepper Brandy Cream Sauce, Vegetable of the Day","price":"55.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Pasta","description":"Gluten Free Penne Pasta Available","items":[{"title":"Capellini Pomodoro**","description":"Italian Plum Tomato, Shaved Parmesan, Finished with Shaved Zucchini, Squash, Carrots","price":"32.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Jumbo Prawns Alfredo","description":"Linguine, Alfredo Sauce, Shaved Parmesan, Basil","price":"42.00","variationGroups":[{"items":[{"title":"Sub Chicken","price":"38.00","__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuVariationGroup"}],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Seafood Pasta**","description":"Shrimp, Scallops, Mahi, Sundried Tomato Cream Sauce, Linguine Pasta, Shaved Parmesan","price":"48.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"}],"updated":"2025-04-02T01:10:36.678","provider":{"name":"SinglePlatform","image":{"altText":"","url":"https://a.singleplatform.com/OpenTable/butterfly-cafe/provided_by_2.png?sp_dt=20230428","height":21,"__typename":"ProviderImage"},"__typename":"MenuProvider"},"__typename":"Menu"},{"title":"Desserts & After-Dinner Drinks","description":"","currency":{"code":"USD","__typename":"MenuCurrency"},"sections":[{"title":"Desserts","description":"","items":[{"title":"Award Winning Key Lime Pie","description":"Traditional key lime pie topped with a layer of white chocolate mousse and a chocolate wafer crust with almond flour","price":"14.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"TDF","description":"Pink Shrimp, Traditional Cocktail Sauce","price":"14.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Crème Brûlée","description":"Tahitian vanilla bean, Two petite servings","price":"16.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Flourless Chocolate Cake","description":"Warm chocolate cake drenched in a chocolate sauce with a spoon of raspberry sorbet","price":"14.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Cheesecake","description":"Jicama Slaw, Chipotle Aioli","price":"14.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Raspberry Sorbet","description":"","price":"8.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Vanilla Ice Cream","description":"","price":"8.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"After Dinner Drinks","description":"","items":[{"title":"Macallan 12 Year","description":"","price":"24.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Oban 14 Year","description":"","price":"22.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Glenlivet 12 Year","description":"","price":"17.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Balvenie 14 Year","description":"","price":"19.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Basil Hayden","description":"","price":"18.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Glenlivet 18 Year","description":"","price":"28.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Woodford Rev","description":"","price":"17.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Balvenie 12 Year","description":"","price":"17.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Glenfiddich 14 Year","description":"","price":"18.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Espresso Martini","description":"Vanilla Vodka ~ Kahlua Licor 43 ~ Espresso Coffee","price":"18.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Chocolate Martini","description":"Chocolate Vodka ~ Crème de Cacao ~ Godiva Dark Chocolate","price":"16.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Lattini","description":"Vanilla Vodka ~ Kahlua ~ Baileys ~ Licor 43 ~ Espresso Coffee","price":"18.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Brandy Alexander Martini","description":"Brandy ~ Crème de Cacao ~ Cream","price":"16.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Key Lime Martini","description":"Vanilla Vodka ~ Licor 43 ~ Lime Juice Cream","price":"16.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Grasshopper Martini","description":"Vodka ~ Crème de Cacao ~ Crème de Menthe ~ Cream","price":"16.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Featured After Dinner Coffees","description":"","items":[{"title":"Affogato","description":"Vanilla ice cream & espresso with your choice of Cordial","price":"21.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Build Your Own Specialty Coffee","description":"Irish Whiskey, Amaretto, Kahlua, Sambuca, Baileys, Grand Marnier, Frangelico","price":"14.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Ports - Ice Wine","description":"","items":[{"title":"Ramos Pinto Porto Ruby","description":"","price":"10.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Sandeman Founders Reserve","description":"","price":"12.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Sandeman Tawny Porto 10 Year","description":"","price":"14.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Sandeman Tawny Porto 20 Year","description":"","price":"16.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Inniskillin","description":"","price":"20.00","variationGroups":[{"items":[{"title":"Glass","price":"20.00","__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Bottle","price":"75.00","__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuVariationGroup"}],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Cognacs","description":"","items":[{"title":"Courvoisier VS","description":"","price":"16.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Courvoisier VSOP","description":"","price":"18.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Remy VSOP","description":"","price":"18.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Remy 1738","description":"","price":"20.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"}],"updated":"2025-04-02T01:10:41.048","provider":{"name":"SinglePlatform","image":{"altText":"","url":"https://a.singleplatform.com/OpenTable/butterfly-cafe/provided_by_2.png?sp_dt=20230428","height":21,"__typename":"ProviderImage"},"__typename":"MenuProvider"},"__typename":"Menu"},{"title":"Little Caterpillars Children's Menu","description":"","currency":{"code":"USD","__typename":"MenuCurrency"},"sections":[{"title":"Main","description":"","items":[{"title":"Hot Dog","description":"French Fries","price":"15.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Cheese Pizza","description":"","price":"19.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Grilled Cheese","description":"French Fries","price":"14.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Chicken Fingers","description":"French Fries","price":"18.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Mahi Mahi Bites","description":"Mashed Potato and Vegetables","price":"20.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Pasta","description":"$17","items":[{"title":"Butter and Parmesan Cheese","description":"","price":null,"variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Mac & Cheese Sauce","description":"","price":null,"variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Tomato Sauce","description":"","price":null,"variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Desserts","description":"","items":[{"title":"Brownie Sundae","description":"","price":"14.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Vanilla Ice Cream","description":"","price":"18.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"}],"updated":"2025-01-12T01:08:57.676","provider":{"name":"SinglePlatform","image":{"altText":"","url":"https://a.singleplatform.com/OpenTable/butterfly-cafe/provided_by_2.png?sp_dt=20230428","height":21,"__typename":"ProviderImage"},"__typename":"MenuProvider"},"__typename":"Menu"}],"menuInfo":{"showThirdPartyMenu":true,"url":null,"__typename":"MenuInfo"}},"isHuman":false,"metaLinks":{"isIndexed":false,"hrefLangs":[{"href":"https://www.opentable.com/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"en-US","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.com/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon?lang=es","hrefLang":"es-US","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.jp/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"ja-JP","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.de/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"de-DE","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.es/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"es-ES","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.ca/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"en-CA","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.ca/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon?lang=fr","hrefLang":"fr-CA","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.hk/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"en-HK","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.ie/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"en-IE","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.sg/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"en-SG","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.nl/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"nl-NL","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.com.mx/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"es-MX","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.co.uk/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"en-GB","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.com.au/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"en-AU","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.ae/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"en-AE","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.co.th/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"en-TH","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.it/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"it-IT","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.com.tw/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"zh-TW","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.fr/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","hrefLang":"fr-FR","__typename":"HrefLang"}],"canonical":"https://www.opentable.ie/r/butterfly-cafe-marathon","__typename":"PageMetaData"},"reviewsData":{"reviewSearchResults":{"reviews":[{"reviewId":"OT-293512-21341-170047149427","text":"We had a great table outside. The weather was perfect, the wine was cold, the food was delicious, and the service was outstanding! A perfect night in paradise.","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":5,"noise":"MODERATE","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":3,"nickname":"John","metro":{"metroId":8,"displayName":"New York City","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"J","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"PLUM","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-05-03T14:37:01Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-05-02T19:00:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-21244-150205302305","text":"Fantastic dinner with a great staff. The meal was perfect. The dessert, key lime pie was out of this world. Would come back for the pie. In fact, might tonight.","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":5,"noise":"DO_NOT_RECALL","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":3,"nickname":"Stacie","metro":{"metroId":80,"displayName":"Central Coast","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"S","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"ICECREAM","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-04-27T21:51:40Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-04-25T19:30:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[{"photoId":"77114379","type":null,"photoMetaData":{"title":null,"source":"Diner","creator":"OpenTable","timestamp":"2025-04-27T21:51:44Z","photoBySize":{"small":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/small/1/77114379.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"medium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/medium/1/77114379.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"xlarge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/xlarge/1/77114379.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideMedium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-medium/1/77114379.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideLarge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-large/1/77114379.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"__typename":"PhotoSizes"},"__typename":"PhotoMetadata"},"caption":"Key lime pie","showCaption":true,"__typename":"ReviewPhoto"}],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-21214-100176956180","text":"We dined outside on the patio and the atmosphere and music was perfect. It is probably one of the pricier restaurants in the area but we felt it was worth it. It was our favorite meal while in Marathon. The crab cakes and risotto with scallops was perfect. We had good service and thoroughly enjoyed our experience there.","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":5,"noise":"QUIET","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":2,"nickname":"Sarah","metro":{"metroId":427,"displayName":"Coastal Georgia","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"S","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"MUSTARD","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-04-25T15:04:38Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-04-24T19:00:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-20934-100115275580","text":"Cowboy ribeye was terrific \nsignature dish of scallops and risotto never disappoints\nbeautiful setting","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":5,"noise":"DO_NOT_RECALL","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":1,"nickname":"keith","metro":{"metroId":370,"displayName":"Northern MI","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"k","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"MUSTARD","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-04-23T11:43:02Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-04-22T18:30:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-17704-130031861653","text":"Service was great ! Highly recommend the Key Lime Martini. We really enjoyed our dinner in this beautiful restaurant!","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":4,"noise":"QUIET","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":2,"nickname":"Rebecca","metro":{"metroId":13,"displayName":"Philadelphia","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"R","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"ICECREAM","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-04-22T01:57:42Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-04-21T18:45:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-20864-130042068843","text":"Just an amazing dinner to end our vacation and celebrate our friends birthday! Food and atmosphere were perfect!!! Will definitely come back!! highly recommend!","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":5,"noise":"QUIET","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":4,"nickname":"Barbara","metro":{"metroId":28,"displayName":"Orlando","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"B","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"PLUM","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-04-11T17:44:35Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-04-09T20:30:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-20812-160026992086","text":"Everything was wonderful our service was excellent!! I think our girl was Jan I’m not 100% on the name but she was fantastic! Everyone was !! Tu great experience!! Fantastic food!!","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":5,"noise":"QUIET","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":13,"nickname":"Michele","metro":{"metroId":13,"displayName":"Philadelphia","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"M","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"PUMPKIN","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-04-11T01:18:58Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-04-09T19:30:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-20328-100022408880","text":"Really nice relaxing dining experience. Food was delicious and the key lime pie was an amazing finish to the meal!","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":4,"noise":"QUIET","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":13,"nickname":"Kristi","metro":{"metroId":13,"displayName":"Philadelphia","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"K","isVip":true,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"MUSTARD","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-04-06T14:27:21Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-04-05T19:00:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-20755-110014541901","text":"Food was amazing. Good service. You need a reservation. A lot of families with babies and toddlers but that’s to be expected in a resort restaurant. The staff was good about seating us, as a couple, away from big parties. Best meal of our trip!","rating":{"food":5,"service":4,"ambience":4,"value":4,"noise":"QUIET","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":35,"nickname":"Gina","metro":{"metroId":8,"displayName":"New York City","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"G","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"ICECREAM","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-05-03T21:54:01Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-04-04T19:15:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-293512-20752-150095911285","text":"The resort is beautiful, as is the restaurant. The food was good a bit too pricey.","rating":{"food":4,"service":5,"ambience":4,"value":3,"noise":"MODERATE","overall":4,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":3,"nickname":"John","metro":{"metroId":85,"displayName":"Key West","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"J","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"ICECREAM","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-04-06T02:29:23Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-04-04T18:00:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"}],"totalPages":48,"page":1,"totalCount":478,"__typename":"ReviewSearchResults"},"reviewHelpfulnessVotes":[],"sortBy":"newestReview","isLoading":false,"prioritiseUserLanguage":false,"searchTerm":"","error":false},"availabilityToken":"eyJ2IjoyLCJtIjoxLCJwIjowLCJzIjowLCJuIjowfQ","noAvailabilityList":null,"multiDayAvailabilityModalOpen":false,"showDiningReward":false,"initialDTPDate":null,"initialDTPTime":null,"initialDTPPartySize":null,"fetchAvailabilityOnLoad":false,"findATableLoadingStateOverride":true,"pointRedemptionRewards":null,"privateDining":{},"activeTab":"overview","disableFPC":true,"restaurantHighlights":{"staff":null,"missionStatement":null},"pageAnchor":null},"wallet":{"isPaymentLoading":false,"singleUseCard":null,"savedCards":[],"selectedPaymentCardId":null,"showAddPaymentsMethodModal":false,"showConfirmDeleteModal":false,"cardIdForDeletion":null,"paymentCardTokenToSaveAfterLogin":null,"errorCode":null,"showPaymentMethodSavedToast":null,"showPaymentMethodRemovedToast":null,"networkError":null,"partialErrors":[]}},"__OT_NEW_SESSION_START__":false,"__EXCLUDE_ONETRUST__":false,"__EXCLUDE_GA__":false,"__INCLUDE_RECAPTCHA__":false,"__OT_RUM_CONTEXT__":{"deviceType":"desktop","primaryCountry":"ie"},"__OT_GA_DATA__":{"cd2":11,"cd12":"en","cd6":293512,"cd28":293512,"cd13":"Full Web","cd17":"Full Web","cd11":"restprofilepage","cd66":"restaurants","cd63":"restaurant-profile","cd67":"network","cd10":"anonymous","cd7":"Logged Out","cd4":190,"cd76":190,"cd3":85,"cd19":85,"cd78":9011,"cd5":9011,"cd31":"false","cd85":1,"cd84":"GuestCenter","cd15":"network","cd18":"network"}}}
Serving ocean food platters in the scenic bay views of Tranquility Bay, Butterfly Café is a full service restaurant ladling seafood dinners to the lodgers and visiting gourmets. Customers can dine in the upscale elegant indoors furnished with wicker seats and grommet curtains or relax in the outdoor patio at Butterfly Cafe.
Important note: To guarantee outdoor dining with us please select "Outdoor" Seating at booking. Standard seating is indoors. If Outdoor Seating is not an option when you book, all outdoor tables are reserved at the time you selected.
Butterfly Café reviews from people who’ve dined at this restaurant. Based on recent rating.
Overall ratings and reviews
Reviews can only be made by diners who have eaten at this restaurant
4.6
4.6 based on recent ratings
4.6Food
4.5Service
4.8Ambience
4.1Value
Noise • Moderate
Diners' Choice Awards
Key West / Florida Keys
Best Ambience
Key West / Florida Keys
American
Florida Keys - Monroe County
Best Ambience
Florida Keys - Monroe County
American
Review summary
AI-generated from verified diner reviews
Butterfly Café offers a "beautiful setting" and "excellent service," with standout dishes like "scallops and risotto" and "stuffed hogfish." Guests appreciate the "relaxing atmosphere" and "delicious desserts" like the "TDF date cake." While some find it "pricey," the overall "dining experience" is praised, making it "worth every penny."
478 Reviews
J
John
New York City3 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
We had a great table outside. The weather was perfect, the wine was cold, the food was delicious, and the service was outstanding! A perfect night in paradise.
Is this helpful?
S
Stacie
Central Coast3 reviews
5.0
Dined on 25 April 2025
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
Fantastic dinner with a great staff. The meal was perfect. The dessert, key lime pie was out of this world. Would come back for the pie. In fact, might tonight.
Is this helpful?
S
Sarah
Coastal Georgia2 reviews
5.0
Dined on 24 April 2025
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
We dined outside on the patio and the atmosphere and music was perfect. It is probably one of the pricier restaurants in the area but we felt it was worth it. It was our favorite meal while in Marathon. The crab cakes and risotto with scallops was perfect. We had good service and thoroughly enjoyed our experience there.
Is this helpful?
k
keith
Northern MI1 review
5.0
Dined on 22 April 2025
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
Cowboy ribeye was terrific
signature dish of scallops and risotto never disappoints
beautiful setting
Is this helpful?
R
Rebecca
Philadelphia2 reviews
5.0
Dined on 21 April 2025
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
Service was great ! Highly recommend the Key Lime Martini. We really enjoyed our dinner in this beautiful restaurant!
Is this helpful?
B
Barbara
Orlando4 reviews
5.0
Dined on 10 April 2025
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
Just an amazing dinner to end our vacation and celebrate our friends birthday! Food and atmosphere were perfect!!! Will definitely come back!! highly recommend!
Is this helpful?
M
Michele
Philadelphia13 reviews
5.0
Dined on 9 April 2025
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
Everything was wonderful our service was excellent!! I think our girl was Jan I’m not 100% on the name but she was fantastic! Everyone was !! Tu great experience!! Fantastic food!!
Is this helpful?
K
Kristi VIP
Philadelphia13 reviews
5.0
Dined on 5 April 2025
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
Really nice relaxing dining experience. Food was delicious and the key lime pie was an amazing finish to the meal!
Is this helpful?
G
Gina
New York City35 reviews
5.0
Dined on 4 April 2025
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 4
Ambience 4
Food was amazing. Good service. You need a reservation. A lot of families with babies and toddlers but that’s to be expected in a resort restaurant. The staff was good about seating us, as a couple, away from big parties. Best meal of our trip!
Is this helpful?
J
John
Key West3 reviews
4.0
Dined on 4 April 2025
Overall 4
Food 4
Service 5
Ambience 4
The resort is beautiful, as is the restaurant. The food was good a bit too pricey.
Is this helpful?
FAQs
Butterfly Café offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (305) 289-7177.
Butterfly Café is rated 4.6 stars by 478 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable.