Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York City
  4. Manhattan
  5. Upper East Side
Island, New York, NY

Island

4.7
4.7
1165 Reviews
$31 to $50
American

Make a booking

2 people
19:00
Booked 33 times today

About this restaurant

  • Neighbourhood gem
  • Charming
  • Great for brunch
Welcome to Island. We have proudly been the neighborhood favorite in Carnegie Hill since we opened our doors in 1986. We take pride to offer the freshest seafood (think Jumbo Lump Crabcakes, Lobster Roll, Maple Glazed Salmon or Ahi Tuna Poke Bowl to name a few), a great variety of fresh salads, a burger that people die for and much more. We have a bar where you can dine or simply enjoy a cocktail or a glass of of wine (our entire wine list is served by the glass). Our warm and thoughtful service is hard to find in New York and is what continues to keep our customers coming back. We hope that you will come give Island a try and become one of our new regulars!

Please note that we cannot take reservations for specific tables or specific sections though we will do our best to accommodate a request.

Order delivery or takeout

Dining areas

Additional information

  • Dining style
    Casual Elegant
  • Price
    $31 to $50
  • Cuisines
    American
  • Hours of Operation
    Mon–Fri 11:30 am–10:30 pm Sat 11:00 am–11:00 pm Sun 11:00 am–10:00 pm
  • Phone number
    (212) 996-1200
  • Website
    http://islandny.com/
  • Payment Options
    AMEX, Diners Club, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Dress code
    Smart Casual
  • Catering
    We are pleased to offer catering services to make your event special. Please call the restaurant to inquire.
  • Private party facilities
    We are pleased to host private events of varying sizes. Please call the restaurant to inquire.

Menu

Island's menu was last updated 2023-12-07.

Starters

  • Hummus + PitaUS$15.00

    hummus drizzled w. olive oil

    • Roasted Tomato SoupUS$13.00

      light on cream + served w. a parmesan crisp

      • Portobello BruschettaUS$15.00

        marinated portobello mushroom w. melted parmesan + swiss cheese over grilled garlic sourdough bread w. a drizzle of balsamic glaze + chopped parsley

        • GuacamoleUS$15.00

          w. tortilla chips

          • Crispy Fried CalamariUS$17.00

            tartar + spiced tomato sauce

            • Shrimp CocktailUS$20.00

              four jumbo shrimp w. cilantro cocktail sauce

              Salads

              • Nicoise SaladUS$26.00

                yellowfin tuna, olive, hard boiled egg, potato, tomato, green been + capers over a bed of mesclun greens w. red wine shallot vinaigrette

                • Apple Walnut SaladUS$18.50

                  baby arugula, endive, honey crisp apple, walnut, goat cheese + dried cranberry w. red wine-maple vinaigrette

                  • Chopped Cobb SaladUS$22.00

                    organic roasted chicken, avocado, bacon, hard boiled egg, blue cheese, tomato + sherry shallot vinaigrette

                    • Curried Chicken SaladUS$20.00

                      watercress, apple, red onion, endive + toasted almonds

                      • Spring Kale SaladUS$20.00

                        chopped kale tossed w. roasted corn, heirloom cherry tomato, avocado, queso fresco, tortilla strips and a cilantro lime vinaigrette

                        • Caesar SaladUS$16.50

                          baby romaine lettuce w. house made parmesan croutons

                          Entrees

                          • Caprese PaniniUS$19.00

                            mozzarella cheese, beefsteak tomato, basil, salt, pepper, w. olive oil + balsamic glaze on sourdough bread w. french fries

                            • Maine Lobster RollUS$35.00

                              w. coleslaw + french fries

                              • Island BurgerUS$21.00

                                grass fed beef + brisket blend w. pickles, tomato, boston lettuce + french fries

                                • Grilled Salmon BowlUS$28.00

                                  over farro w. cole slaw, avocado, cucumber + cherry tomato w. ginger vinaigrette

                                  • Crab Cake SlidersUS$25.00

                                    w. side arugula vinagrette salad, chipotle mayo dipping sauce + sweet potato fries

                                    • Tuna Poke BowlUS$27.00

                                      sushi grade tuna, ponzu sauce, avocado, cucumber, + crisp greens w. sesame seeds over basmati rice w. a drizzle of chipotle mayo

                                      • Yellowfin Tuna BurgerUS$25.00

                                        fresh ginger, wasabi mayo + sweet potato fries

                                        • Avocado ToastUS$18.00

                                          mashed avocado, feta cheese, heirloom cherry tomato + olive oil sprinkled w. chili flakes + a side mesclun green salad

                                          • Maine Lobster QuesadillaUS$21.00

                                            papaya glaze, wisconsin brie, pico de gallo + avocado

                                            • The Chicken MeltUS$19.00

                                              organic roasted chicken, mozzarella cheese, arugula, salt, pepper, lite mayonnaise + balsamic vinaigrette on pressed on sourdough bread + french fries

                                              • Island BLTUS$19.00

                                                applewood smoked bacon, boston lettuce, heirloom tomato, salt, pepper + mayonaise on grilled sourdough + french fries

                                                • Classic Grilled CheeseUS$19.00

                                                  applewood smoked bacon, cheddar cheese, roasted tomato on grilled white bread w. sweet potato fries + chipotle mayo dipping sauce

                                                  • PenneUS$23.00

                                                    plum tomato, basil + mozzarella cheese

                                                    • FrittataUS$17.50

                                                      whole egg, spinach, goat cheese + roasted tomato w. a side mesclun green salad (+$2. egg white)

                                                      Sides

                                                      • Sweet Potato FriesUS$7.00

                                                        w. chipotle mayo dipping sauce

                                                        • French FriesUS$7.00

                                                          Sweets

                                                          • Warm Chocolate BrownieUS$11.00

                                                            w. chocolate sauce + vanilla bean gelato

                                                            • Donut HolesUS$13.00

                                                              w. caramel dipping sauce + whipped cream

                                                              • Blueberry CobblerUS$12.00

                                                                w. vanilla bean gelato

                                                                • Key Lime Meringue PieUS$11.00

                                                                  • Apple Tarte TatinUS$12.00

                                                                    w. creme fraiche

                                                                    • Chocolate Chip CookiesUS$8.00

                                                                      • Fresh Seasonal BerriesUS$12.00

                                                                        w. whipped cream + mint

                                                                        • Milk ShakeUS$10.00

                                                                          your choice of up to two gelatos, whipped cream + sprinkles

                                                                          • GelatoUS$5.00

                                                                            vanilla bean, chocolate, strawberry, pistachio

                                                                            • 1 ScoopUS$4.00
                                                                            • 3 ScoopsUS$9.50

                                                                          • SorbetUS$5.00

                                                                            mango, lemon, raspberry

                                                                            • 1 ScoopUS$4.00
                                                                            • 3 ScoopsUS$9.50

                                                                          Last updated: 7 December 2023

                                                                          What 1,165 people are saying

                                                                          Island reviews from people who’ve dined at this restaurant. Based on recent rating.

                                                                          Overall ratings and reviews

                                                                          Reviews can only be made by diners who have eaten at this restaurant

                                                                          4.7
                                                                          4.7 based on recent ratings
                                                                          • 4.6Food
                                                                          • 4.7Service
                                                                          • 4.5Ambience
                                                                          • 4.4Value

                                                                          Noise • Moderate

                                                                          Review summary

                                                                          AI-generated from verified diner reviews
                                                                          Island is a beloved neighborhood gem, praised for its "wonderful food," "professional and friendly" service, and charming atmosphere. Guests love its diverse menu, efficient staff, and warm, welcoming vibe. While some experiences vary, many diners return for its consistent quality, making it a "go-to" spot for locals.

                                                                          1,165 Reviews

                                                                          1. Parmelia VIP

                                                                            New York City11 reviews

                                                                            3.0

                                                                            Dined 2 days ago

                                                                            1. Overall 3
                                                                            2. Food 4
                                                                            3. Service 4
                                                                            4. Ambience 3
                                                                            Great food, wonderful service, but super squashed together tables and REALLY loud. Remove at least 3 tables, so there’s more elbow room!

                                                                            1 person found this helpful

                                                                          2. Theodora VIP

                                                                            Los Angeles56 reviews

                                                                            5.0

                                                                            Dined 2 days ago

                                                                            1. Overall 5
                                                                            2. Food 5
                                                                            3. Service 5
                                                                            4. Ambience 5
                                                                            Love the restaurant and the food is great! Wait service fine and enjoyed my lunch.

                                                                            Is this helpful?

                                                                          3. OpenTable Diner

                                                                            New York City1 review

                                                                            5.0

                                                                            Dined 6 days ago

                                                                            1. Overall 5
                                                                            2. Food 5
                                                                            3. Service 5
                                                                            4. Ambience 5
                                                                            Wonderful food delightful service! We will be back soon!
                                                                            IslandResponded 3 days ago
                                                                            Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We're thrilled that you enjoyed both the food and service. We can't wait to welcome you back soon.

                                                                            Is this helpful?

                                                                          4. Robert VIP

                                                                            New York City118 reviews

                                                                            5.0

                                                                            Dined 6 days ago

                                                                            1. Overall 5
                                                                            2. Food 5
                                                                            3. Service 5
                                                                            4. Ambience 5
                                                                            We enjoyed an especially delightful brunch-thx to all the staff at Island-especially John and Remata who served us! Delicious food, great energy and service as always!!
                                                                            IslandResponded 3 days ago
                                                                            We're so happy to hear you had a delightful brunch, Robert! Thanks for your feedback.

                                                                            Is this helpful?

                                                                          5. joanna VIP

                                                                            New York City35 reviews

                                                                            4.0

                                                                            Dined 6 days ago

                                                                            1. Overall 4
                                                                            2. Food 4
                                                                            3. Service 5
                                                                            4. Ambience 4
                                                                            Would go back. So nice they take res for brunch!!
                                                                            IslandResponded 3 days ago
                                                                            Hi Joanna! Thank you so much for the review. Yes, we do, and we’re looking forward to welcoming you again soon.

                                                                            Is this helpful?

                                                                          6. Sudha

                                                                            Minneapolis3 reviews

                                                                            4.0

                                                                            Dined 7 days ago

                                                                            1. Overall 4
                                                                            2. Food 3
                                                                            3. Service 5
                                                                            4. Ambience 5
                                                                            Service was amazing, everyone was so kind and helpful
                                                                            IslandResponded 3 days ago
                                                                            Thank you so much for your kind words, Sudha! We're thrilled to hear that our team provided you with an amazing experience. We appreciate your feedback and look forward to serving you again in the future.

                                                                            Is this helpful?

                                                                          7. Alicia VIP

                                                                            New York City16 reviews

                                                                            4.0

                                                                            Dined on 1 March 2025

                                                                            1. Overall 4
                                                                            2. Food 4
                                                                            3. Service 4
                                                                            4. Ambience 4
                                                                            Food well-prepared and tasty. All enjoyed food and experience.
                                                                            IslandResponded on 5 March 2025
                                                                            Hi Alicia! Thank you for the positive review. We're glad you enjoyed your time at Island and hope to see you again soon.

                                                                            Is this helpful?

                                                                          8. Inna

                                                                            San Francisco1 review

                                                                            5.0

                                                                            Dined on 23 February 2025

                                                                            1. Overall 5
                                                                            2. Food 5
                                                                            3. Service 5
                                                                            4. Ambience 5
                                                                            The food was delicious and the service was great. Thank you!
                                                                            IslandResponded on 26 February 2025
                                                                            Thank you very much for your review, Inna! We're so glad to hear you enjoyed your visit, and we hope to see you again soon.

                                                                            1 person found this helpful

                                                                          9. Robert VIP

                                                                            New York City118 reviews

                                                                            5.0

                                                                            Dined on 21 February 2025

                                                                            1. Overall 5
                                                                            2. Food 5
                                                                            3. Service 5
                                                                            4. Ambience 5
                                                                            Thx again to all at Island allowing us to enjoy a wonderful dining experience! 👏👍
                                                                            IslandResponded on 26 February 2025
                                                                            Hi Robert! Thank you for your kind words. We are glad you enjoyed your experience at Island and appreciate you taking the time to tell us how great your time with us was. We look forward to welcoming you back soon!

                                                                            Is this helpful?

                                                                          10. Robert

                                                                            San Francisco1 review

                                                                            2.0

                                                                            Dined on 14 February 2025

                                                                            1. Overall 2
                                                                            2. Food 3
                                                                            3. Service 3
                                                                            4. Ambience 3
                                                                            Valentine's Day, busy. Seated by the door, so extra busy. Our wait person was super, but overall, he had too many tables to care for, which meant that service for us - being so far from the central area - was slow. Worse, though, was the food. I've eaten here a number of times, and never had a problem. But this time, the food for each of us (two) was lukewarm. It was pretty clear that the food had been prepped and left under the heating lamp too long before serving. The restaurant took my plate of steak frites back, replaced French fries with hotter, fresh fries, but they did nothing with regard to the steak. It came back almost cold. My recommendation? A generally good restaurant that needs to beef up its kitchen and wait staff for busy days.
                                                                            IslandResponded on 16 February 2025
                                                                            Hi Robert! Thank you for sharing your Valentine's Day experience. We're disappointed we didn't meet your expectations due to the busy night. We're addressing the slow service and food temperature issues you mentioned. We value your feedback and hope you'll consider visiting us again soon.

                                                                            1 person found this helpful

                                                                          FAQs

                                                                          Island does offer delivery in partnership with Chow Now. Island also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 996-1200.

                                                                          Island is rated 4.7 stars by 1165 OpenTable diners.

                                                                          Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable.

                                                                          Make a booking

                                                                          2 people
                                                                          19:00
                                                                          Booked 33 times today

                                                                          Order delivery or takeout

                                                                          Google Map for Island

                                                                          1305 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10128

                                                                          Dining areas

                                                                          Additional information

                                                                          • Cross Street
                                                                            92nd & 93rd Sts
                                                                          • Area
                                                                            Upper East Side
                                                                          • Hours of Operation
                                                                            Mon–Fri 11:30 am–10:30 pm Sat 11:00 am–11:00 pm Sun 11:00 am–10:00 pm
                                                                          • Price
                                                                            $31 to $50
                                                                          • Cuisines
                                                                            American
                                                                          • Dining style
                                                                            Casual Elegant
                                                                          • Dress code
                                                                            Smart Casual
                                                                          • Parking details
                                                                            Street Parking
                                                                          • Payment Options
                                                                            AMEX, Diners Club, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
                                                                          • Additional
                                                                            Indoor Fireplace, Patio/Outdoor Dining
                                                                          • Website
                                                                            http://islandny.com/
                                                                          • Phone number
                                                                            (212) 996-1200
                                                                          • Catering
                                                                            We are pleased to offer catering services to make your event special. Please call the restaurant to inquire.
                                                                          • Private party facilities
                                                                            We are pleased to host private events of varying sizes. Please call the restaurant to inquire.
                                                                          Discover
                                                                          OpenTable
                                                                          • About Us
                                                                          • Blog
                                                                          • Careers
                                                                          More
                                                                          Our sites
                                                                          Businesses
                                                                          • Delight more diners
                                                                          • Restaurant Blog
                                                                          Join us on
                                                                          • Privacy policy
                                                                          • Terms of Use
                                                                          • Impressum
                                                                          • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
                                                                          • Cookie Preferences
                                                                          Copyright © 2024 OpenTable International Ltd. Alphabeta Building, 14-18 Finsbury Square, London EC2A 1AH - All rights reserved.
                                                                          OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
                                                                          Booking Logo
                                                                          Priceline Logo
                                                                          KAYAK Logo
                                                                          Agoda Logo
                                                                          OpenTable Logo